Drach-Zahavy Anat
Department of Nursing, Faculty of Health and Welfare, University of Haifa, Haifa, Israel.
J Adv Nurs. 2004 Jan;45(1):7-16. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2648.2003.02855.x.
Most studies examining primary nursing focus on outcome variables such as enhanced patient and staff satisfaction with care, perceived autonomy and quality of care, whereas only limited research has examined processes of implementing and maintaining primary nursing. In addition, the few studies that have explored process variables discuss only direct relationships between the design of the primary nursing care-delivery system, process and nurse outcomes, and disregard how such variables interact.
This study sought to address previous inconsistent findings about the impact of primary nursing care-delivery models on the performance of nurses by incorporating the moderating role of supportive management practices.
Three hundred and sixty-eight nurses from a variety of wards completed questionnaires that assessed the degree of primary nursing on their unit, the support practices of their direct supervisor and their perceptions of the cost of seeking support from their supervisor. In addition, the direct supervisor evaluated the nurse's performance in the unit.
Primary nursing did not exert a direct impact on nurses' performance. Rather, the interaction of primary nursing with supervisor support was more predictive of performance: if supervisor support was high, performance was substantially higher than if supervisor support was low. In addition, nurses' perceptions of the costs of seeking support had a detrimental impact on their performance.
The study was cross-sectional and relied on self-report data only. Nevertheless, the findings show that supportive management practices are crucial to the success of implementing primary nursing.
大多数关于初级护理的研究都聚焦于结果变量,如提高患者和医护人员对护理的满意度、感知到的自主性和护理质量,而仅有有限的研究考察了初级护理的实施和维持过程。此外,少数探索过程变量的研究仅讨论了初级护理服务提供系统的设计、过程与护士结果之间的直接关系,而忽略了这些变量之间的相互作用。
本研究旨在通过纳入支持性管理实践的调节作用,解决先前关于初级护理服务模式对护士绩效影响的不一致研究结果。
来自不同病房的368名护士完成了问卷,问卷评估了其所在科室的初级护理程度、直属上级的支持性实践以及她们对向上级寻求支持成本的看法。此外,直属上级对护士在科室的绩效进行了评估。
初级护理对护士绩效没有直接影响。相反,初级护理与上级支持的相互作用对绩效更具预测性:如果上级支持度高,绩效显著高于上级支持度低的情况。此外,护士对寻求支持成本的看法对其绩效有不利影响。
本研究为横断面研究,仅依赖自我报告数据。尽管如此,研究结果表明支持性管理实践对初级护理实施的成功至关重要。