Ivers Rowena G
Menzies School of Health Research, Northern Territory University.
Aust N Z J Public Health. 2003;27(3):294-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-842x.2003.tb00398.x.
To conduct a review of interventions to reduce the harm resulting from tobacco use among Indigenous Australians and to discuss the likely effect of a range of tobacco interventions if conducted in this population.
A systematic review of medical literature and an audit of information from 32 government departments, non-government organisations and indigenous health organisations, which was completed in March 2001.
A number of small tobacco programs had been conducted. Only four tobacco interventions had been evaluated in indigenous communities: a trial of training health professionals in conducting a brief intervention for smoking cessation; a trial of a CD-ROM on tobacco for use with indigenous schoolchildren; a qualitative evaluation of the effect of a mainstream advertising campaign on Indigenous people; and a pilot study of smoke-free workplaces, evaluated by qualitative methods. None of these studies assessed smoking cessation as an outcome. Two of these studies were unable to conclusively show any effect of the interventions; training health professionals in delivering a brief intervention resulted in some changes to practice and the evaluation of the mainstream advertising campaign showed that following the campaign, knowledge about tobacco had increased.
There was a major lack of research on and evaluation of tobacco interventions for Indigenous Australians.
More research and evaluation is required to ensure that tobacco interventions are appropriate and effective for Indigenous people. It is time to cease chronicling the ill health of Indigenous Australians and time to ensure the availability of well-evaluated, effective tobacco programs.
对减少澳大利亚原住民烟草使用危害的干预措施进行综述,并讨论一系列烟草干预措施若在此人群中实施可能产生的效果。
对医学文献进行系统综述,并对来自32个政府部门、非政府组织和原住民健康组织的信息进行审核,该审核于2001年3月完成。
已开展了一些小型烟草项目。在原住民社区仅对四项烟草干预措施进行了评估:一项关于培训卫生专业人员进行简短戒烟干预的试验;一项关于供原住民学童使用的烟草主题光盘的试验;对一项主流广告活动对原住民影响的定性评估;以及一项采用定性方法评估的无烟工作场所试点研究。这些研究均未将戒烟作为一项结果进行评估。其中两项研究无法确凿显示干预措施产生了任何效果;培训卫生专业人员进行简短干预导致了一些实践上的改变,对主流广告活动的评估表明,活动开展后,有关烟草的知识有所增加。
对于针对澳大利亚原住民的烟草干预措施,严重缺乏研究和评估。
需要进行更多研究和评估,以确保烟草干预措施对原住民是适当且有效的。是时候停止记录澳大利亚原住民的健康不佳状况了,是时候确保提供经过充分评估的有效烟草项目了。