Nelson M, Poulter J
Department of Nutrition and Dietetics, King's College London, London, UK.
J Hum Nutr Diet. 2004 Feb;17(1):43-54. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-277x.2003.00497.x.
The aims of this review are (1) to evaluate the literature on the likely impact of tea drinking on the iron status of different groups within the UK population and (2) to formulate targeted and evidence based advice on tea drinking in the context of iron nutrition in different groups of people.
A literature search identified 35 references specific to the effects of black tea on iron absorption and iron nutrition plus one recent review article. Each study was assessed in terms of methodogical quality and relevance to the tea drinking patterns of the UK population.
There is clear evidence to show that tea drinking limits the absorption of nonhaem iron. However, there are few studies which have assessed the influence of tea drinking on indicators of iron status. There are no intervention studies and the conclusions reported in this review are based on 12 observational studies mostly from other countries. These studies have reported either significant negative correlations between tea drinking and blood indicators of iron status or more cases of anemia in tea drinkers compared with nontea drinkers. Many of the studies reviewed report additional relationships between iron status indices and other factors (both dietary and nondietary), highlighting the complexity of influences on iron absorption and iron status.
From the available evidence there is no need to advise any restriction on tea drinking in healthy people with no risk of iron deficiency. In groups at risk of iron deficiency the advice should be to drink tea between meals and to wait at least 1 h after eating before drinking tea.
本综述的目的是:(1)评估关于饮茶对英国人群中不同群体铁状态可能产生的影响的文献;(2)针对不同人群的铁营养状况,制定基于证据的关于饮茶的针对性建议。
文献检索确定了35篇关于红茶对铁吸收和铁营养影响的特定参考文献以及一篇近期的综述文章。对每项研究都从方法学质量以及与英国人群饮茶模式的相关性方面进行了评估。
有明确证据表明饮茶会限制非血红素铁的吸收。然而,很少有研究评估饮茶对铁状态指标的影响。没有干预性研究,本综述所报告的结论基于12项大多来自其他国家的观察性研究。这些研究报告了饮茶与铁状态血液指标之间显著的负相关,或者饮茶者中贫血病例比不饮茶者更多。许多被综述的研究报告了铁状态指标与其他因素(饮食和非饮食因素)之间的额外关系,突出了对铁吸收和铁状态影响的复杂性。
根据现有证据,对于没有缺铁风险的健康人,无需建议限制饮茶。对于有缺铁风险的人群,建议在两餐之间饮茶,并且在进食后至少等待1小时再饮茶。