Forster Alan J, Clark Heather D, Menard Alex, Dupuis Natalie, Chernish Robert, Chandok Natasha, Khan Asmat, van Walraven Carl
Clinical Epidemiology Program, Ottawa Health Research Institute, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
CMAJ. 2004 Feb 3;170(3):345-9.
Adverse events (AEs) are adverse outcomes caused by medical care. Several studies have indicated that a substantial number of patients experience AEs before or during hospitalization. However, few data describe AEs after hospital discharge. We determined the incidence, severity, preventability and ameliorability of AEs in patients discharged from the general internal medicine service of a Canadian hospital.
At a multisite Canadian teaching hospital, we prospectively studied patients who were consecutively discharged home or to a seniors' residence from the general internal medicine service during a 14-week interval in 2002. We used telephone interview and chart review to identify outcomes after discharge. Two physicians independently reviewed each outcome to determine if the patient experienced an AE. The severity, preventability and ameliorability of all AEs were classified.
During the study period, outcomes were determined for 328 of the 361 eligible patients, who averaged 71 years of age (interquartile range 54-81 years). After discharge, 76 of the 328 patients experienced at least 1 AE (overall incidence 23%, 95% confidence interval [CI] 19%-28%). The AE severity ranged from symptoms only (68% of the AEs) or symptoms associated with a nonpermanent disability (25%) to permanent disability (3%) or death (3%). The most common AEs were adverse drug events (72%), therapeutic errors (16%) and nosocomial infections (11%). Of the 76 patients, 38 had an AE that was either preventable or ameliorable (overall incidence 12%, 95% CI 9%-16%).
Approximately one-quarter of patients in our study had an AE after hospital discharge, and half of the AEs were preventable or ameliorable.
不良事件(AE)是由医疗护理导致的不良后果。多项研究表明,大量患者在住院前或住院期间会经历不良事件。然而,很少有数据描述出院后的不良事件。我们确定了加拿大一家医院普通内科出院患者不良事件的发生率、严重程度、可预防性和可改善性。
在加拿大一家多院区教学医院,我们对2002年14周期间从普通内科连续出院回家或入住老年公寓的患者进行了前瞻性研究。我们通过电话访谈和病历审查来确定出院后的结局。两名医生独立审查每个结局,以确定患者是否经历了不良事件。对所有不良事件的严重程度、可预防性和可改善性进行分类。
在研究期间,确定了361名符合条件患者中的328名患者的结局,这些患者的平均年龄为71岁(四分位间距54 - 81岁)。出院后,328名患者中有76名至少经历了1次不良事件(总体发生率23%,95%置信区间[CI] 19% - 28%)。不良事件的严重程度从仅出现症状(占不良事件的68%)或与非永久性残疾相关的症状(25%)到永久性残疾(3%)或死亡(3%)不等。最常见的不良事件是药物不良事件(72%)、治疗失误(16%)和医院感染(11%)。在这76名患者中,38名患者发生的不良事件是可预防或可改善的(总体发生率12%,95% CI 9% - 16%)。
在我们的研究中,约四分之一的患者出院后发生了不良事件,且一半的不良事件是可预防或可改善的。