Hurd H S, McKean J D, Griffith R D, Rostagno M H
Pre-Harvest Food Safety and Enteric Diseases Research Unit, USDA, Agricultural Research/2 Unit, Ames, IA 50010-0070, USA.
Epidemiol Infect. 2004 Jan;132(1):127-35. doi: 10.1017/s0950268803001249.
The study objective was to evaluate three methods of Salmonella enterica prevalence estimation in swine herds (faecal culture, culture of abattoir-collected samples, and serum ELISA). From each of six swine herds, we necropsied approximately 100 finishing pigs (> 70 kg); one-half on farm and the other half at the abattoir, after transport and approximately 2.5 h holding. We collected the same samples for S. enterica culture at both locations (1 g faecal, 10 g caecal contents, ileocaecal lymph nodes, superficial inguinal lymph nodes, 25 g of gluteal muscle for serum ELISA). On farm, the 1 g faecal sample only detected 13.3% (2/15) of all positive pigs necropsied on farm. However, with abattoir and on-farm results combined, the faecal sample detected 57.4% (74/129) of positive pigs. Abattoir-collected samples provided prevalence estimates much higher than on-farm collected samples (39.9 vs. 5.3%; P < 0.001). This study shows that faecal samples have a low sensitivity for detecting infected pigs and that abattoir-collected samples overestimate the on-farm S. enterica prevalence. For most herds, serology overestimated the on-farm culture prevalence.
本研究的目的是评估猪群中肠炎沙门氏菌流行率的三种估算方法(粪便培养、屠宰场采集样本培养和血清ELISA)。从六个猪群中各选取约100头育肥猪(>70千克)进行剖检;一半在农场剖检,另一半在屠宰场剖检,运输后并经过约2.5小时的停留。我们在两个地点采集相同的样本用于肠炎沙门氏菌培养(1克粪便、10克盲肠内容物、回盲部淋巴结、腹股沟浅淋巴结、25克臀肌用于血清ELISA)。在农场,1克粪便样本仅检测出在农场剖检的所有阳性猪中的13.3%(2/15)。然而,将屠宰场和农场的结果相结合,粪便样本检测出57.4%(74/129)的阳性猪。屠宰场采集的样本提供的流行率估算值远高于农场采集的样本(39.9%对5.3%;P<0.001)。本研究表明,粪便样本检测感染猪的敏感性较低,且屠宰场采集的样本高估了农场肠炎沙门氏菌的流行率。对于大多数猪群,血清学高估了农场的培养流行率。