Rossini Paolo M, Dal Forno Gloria
Department of Clinical Neuroscience, Hospital Fatebenefratelli, Isola Tiberina 39, 00186-Rome, Italy.
Phys Med Rehabil Clin N Am. 2004 Feb;15(1):263-306. doi: 10.1016/s1047-9651(03)00124-4.
The study of neural plasticity has expanded rapidly in the past decades and has shown the remarkable ability of the developing, adult, and aging brain to be shaped by environmental inputs in health and after a lesion. Robust experimental evidence supports the hypothesis that neuronal aggregates adjacent to a lesion in the sensorimotor brain areas can take over progressively the function previously played by the damaged neurons. It definitely is accepted that such a reorganization modifies sensibly the interhemispheric differences in somatotopic organization of the sensorimotor cortices. This reorganization largely subtends clinical recovery of motor performances and sensorimotor integration after a stroke. Brain functional imaging studies show that recovery from hemiplegic strokes is associated with a marked reorganization of the activation patterns of specific brain structures. To regain hand motor control, the recovery process tends over time to bring the bilateral motor network activation toward a more normal intensity/extent, while overrecruiting simultaneously new areas, perhaps to sustain this process. Considerable intersubject variability exists in activation/hyperactivation pattern changes over time. Some patients display late-appearing dorsolateral prefrontal cortex activation, suggesting the development of "executive" strategies to compensate for the lost function. The AH in stroke often undergoes a significant "remodeling" of sensory and motor hand somatotopy outside the "normal" areas, or enlargement of the hand representation. The UH also undergoes reorganization, although to a lesser degree. Although absolute values of the investigated parameters fluctuate across subjects, secondary to individual anatomic variability, variation is minimal with regards to interhemispheric differences, due to the fact that individual morphometric characters are mirrored in the two hemispheres. Excessive interhemispheric asymmetry of the sensorimotor hand areas seems to be the parameter with highest sensitivity in describing brain reorganization after a monohemispheric lesion, and mapping motor and somatosensory cortical areas through focal TMS, fMRI, PET, EEG, and MEG is useful in studying hand representation and interhemispheric asymmetries in normal and pathologic conditions. TMS and MEG allow the detection of sensorimotor areas reshaping, as a result of either neuronal reorganization or recovery of the previously damaged neural network. These techniques have the advantage of high temporal resolution but also have limitations. TMS provides only bidimensional scalp maps, whereas MEG, even if giving three-dimensional mapping of generator sources, does so by means of inverse procedures that rely on the choice of a mathematical model of the head and the sources. These techniques do not test movement execution and sensorimotor integration as used in everyday life. fMRI and PET may provide the ideal means to integrate the findings obtained with the other two techniques. This multitechnology combined approach is at present the best way to test the presence and amount of plasticity phenomena underlying partial or total recovery of several functions, sensorimotor above all. Dynamic patterns of recovery are emerging progressively from the relevant literature. Enhanced recruitment of the affected cortex, be it spared perilesional tissue, as in the case of cortical stroke, or intact but deafferented cortex, as in subcortical strokes, seems to be the rule, a mechanism especially important in early postinsult stages. The transfer over time of preferential activation toward contralesional cortices, as observed in some cases, seems, however, to reflect a less efficient type of plastic reorganization, with some aspects of maladaptive plasticity. Reinforcing the use of the affected side can cause activation to increase again in the affected side with a corresponding enhancement of clinical function. Activation of the UH MI may represent recruitment of direct (uncrossed) corticospinal tracts and relate more to mirror movements, but it more likely reflects activity redistribution within preexisting bilateral, large-scale motor networks. Finally, activation of areas not normally engaged in the dysfunctional tasks, such as the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex or the superior parietal cortex in motor paralysis, might reflect the implication of compensatory cognitive strategies. An integrated approach with technologies able to investigate functional brain imaging is of considerable value in providing information on the excitability, extension, localization, and functional hierarchy of cortical brain areas. Deepening knowledge of the mechanisms regulating the long-term recovery (even if partial), observed for most neurologic sequelae after neural damage, might prompt newer and more efficacious therapeutic and rehabilitative strategies for neurologic diseases.
在过去几十年中,神经可塑性的研究迅速扩展,已表明发育中的、成年的和衰老的大脑在健康状态以及损伤后具有显著的能力,能够被环境输入所塑造。有力的实验证据支持这样一种假说,即感觉运动脑区损伤附近的神经元聚集体能够逐渐接管先前由受损神经元所发挥的功能。人们明确承认,这种重组显著改变了感觉运动皮层躯体定位组织中的半球间差异。这种重组在很大程度上支撑了中风后运动表现和感觉运动整合的临床恢复。脑功能成像研究表明,偏瘫性中风后的恢复与特定脑结构激活模式的显著重组相关。为了重新获得手部运动控制,随着时间推移,恢复过程倾向于使双侧运动网络激活朝着更正常的强度/范围发展,但同时会过度募集新的区域,或许是为了维持这一过程。随着时间推移,激活/过度激活模式的变化存在相当大的个体间差异。一些患者表现出迟发性的背外侧前额叶皮层激活,这表明发展出了“执行”策略来补偿丧失的功能。中风后的患手在“正常”区域之外常常经历感觉和运动躯体定位的显著“重塑”,或者手部表征扩大。健手也会经历重组,尽管程度较小。尽管所研究参数的绝对值因个体解剖变异而在不同受试者间波动,但由于个体形态特征在两个半球中相互映照,半球间差异方面的变化极小。感觉运动手部区域过度的半球间不对称似乎是描述单半球损伤后脑重组的最敏感参数,并且通过局灶性经颅磁刺激(TMS)、功能磁共振成像(fMRI)、正电子发射断层扫描(PET)、脑电图(EEG)和脑磁图(MEG)来绘制运动和躯体感觉皮层区域,对于研究正常和病理状态下的手部表征及半球间不对称是有用的。TMS和MEG能够检测到由于神经元重组或先前受损神经网络的恢复而导致的感觉运动区域重塑。这些技术具有高时间分辨率的优势,但也有局限性。TMS仅提供二维头皮图,而MEG即使能给出发生器源的三维映射,也是通过依赖于头部和源的数学模型选择的反演程序来实现的。这些技术并未测试日常生活中所使用的运动执行和感觉运动整合。fMRI和PET可能为整合通过其他两种技术获得的结果提供理想手段。这种多技术联合方法目前是测试几种功能(尤其是感觉运动功能)部分或完全恢复背后可塑性现象的存在及程度的最佳方式。相关文献中逐渐浮现出恢复的动态模式。受影响皮层的增强募集,无论是如皮质中风情况下的病灶周围 spared 组织,还是如皮质下中风情况下完整但去传入的皮层,似乎都是规律,这是损伤后早期阶段一种特别重要机制。然而,如在某些情况下所观察到的,随着时间推移优先激活向对侧皮层的转移,似乎反映了一种效率较低的可塑性重组类型,具有一些适应不良可塑性的方面。加强对患侧的使用可导致患侧激活再次增加,并相应增强临床功能。健手运动皮层的激活可能代表直接(未交叉)皮质脊髓束的募集,更多地与镜像运动相关,但更可能反映了预先存在的双侧大规模运动网络内的活动重新分布。最后,通常不参与功能障碍任务的区域(如运动麻痹时的背外侧前额叶皮层或顶上叶皮层)的激活,可能反映了补偿性认知策略的参与。采用能够研究脑功能成像的技术的综合方法,对于提供关于脑皮层区域的兴奋性、范围、定位和功能层级的信息具有相当大的价值。深入了解调节神经损伤后大多数神经后遗症所观察到的长期恢复(即使是部分恢复)的机制,可能会促使针对神经系统疾病产生更新且更有效的治疗和康复策略。