Davenport M, Puricelli V, Farrant P, Hadzic N, Mieli-Vergani G, Portmann B, Howard E R
Department of Paediatric Surgery, King's College Hospital, Denmark Hill, London, England, UK.
J Pediatr Surg. 2004 Apr;39(4):575-81. doi: 10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2003.12.014.
There is a detrimental effect of increasing age on the results of the Kasai portoenterostomy for biliary atresia (BA), and some centers routinely advocate primary liver transplantation for the older infant, irrespective of other criteria. This perception that such infants are indeed irretrievable was tested by retrospective analysis.
All infants who had undergone surgery for BA during the period 1980 through 2000 aged > or =100 days were reviewed. Actuarial survival was calculated using 2 end-points (death and transplantation). A retrospective review of their ultrasonography (n = 12) and preoperative liver histology (n = 22) was also undertaken to ascertain possible predictive criteria.
A total of 422 infants had BA diagnosed during this period, of which 35 (8.2%) were > or =100 days at surgery (median [interquartile range], 133 [range, 108 to 180] days). Surgery included portoenterostomy (n = 26), hepaticojejunostomy (n = 7), and a resection and end-to-end anastomosis (n = 1). A laparotomy only was performed in 1. Five- and 10-year actuarial survival rate with native liver was 45% and 40%, respectively. Currently, 12 (35%) patients are alive with their native liver (8 are anicteric), 9 (28%) have undergone transplantation, and 13 have died. Although there were some survival advantages for types 1 or 2 BA and "noncirrhosis" at time of surgery, neither reached statistical significance. Individual histologic features (eg, degrees of fibrosis, giant cell transformation, bile duct destruction) in the retrospective review of available material were not discriminatory. The finding of a "heterogeneous" parenchyma on ultrasonography was predictive of poor outcome but lacked sensitivity.
The potential for reasonable medium-term survival is present in about one third of infants 100 days or older coming to primary corrective surgery. In the absence of accurate discrimination, the authors continue to favor this option rather than subject all to transplant simply on the basis of age.
年龄增长对胆道闭锁(BA)行肝门空肠吻合术的结果有不利影响,一些中心常规主张对年龄较大的婴儿进行一期肝移植,而不考虑其他标准。通过回顾性分析对这种认为此类婴儿确实无法挽救的观点进行了验证。
对1980年至2000年期间接受BA手术时年龄≥100天的所有婴儿进行了回顾。使用两个终点(死亡和移植)计算精算生存率。还对他们的超声检查(n = 12)和术前肝脏组织学(n = 22)进行了回顾性分析,以确定可能的预测标准。
在此期间共诊断出422例BA婴儿,其中35例(8.2%)手术时年龄≥100天(中位数[四分位间距],133[范围,108至180]天)。手术包括肝门空肠吻合术(n = 26)、肝管空肠吻合术(n = 7)和切除术及端端吻合术(n = 1)。仅进行剖腹探查术的有1例。肝脏自然状态下的5年和10年精算生存率分别为45%和40%。目前,12例(35%)患者肝脏自然存活(8例无黄疸),9例(28%)接受了移植,13例死亡。尽管手术时1型或2型BA以及“非肝硬化”有一些生存优势,但均未达到统计学意义。对现有材料进行回顾性分析时,个体组织学特征(如纤维化程度、巨细胞转化、胆管破坏)并无鉴别意义。超声检查发现“不均匀”实质可预测不良预后,但缺乏敏感性。
约三分之一年龄100天及以上接受一期矫正手术的婴儿有中期合理生存的可能性。在缺乏准确鉴别的情况下,作者继续倾向于这种选择,而不是仅仅基于年龄就让所有婴儿接受移植。