Macias Cathaleene, Jones Danson, Harvey John, Barreira Paul, Harding Courtenay, Rodican Charles
Department of Community Intervention Research, McLean Hospital, Belmont, Massachusetts 02478-9106, USA.
Psychiatr Serv. 2004 Apr;55(4):421-6. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.55.4.421.
This study examined whether the situational factors that contribute to severe grief in the general population predicted the severity of grief in a sample of persons who had diagnoses of serious mental illness.
Research participants who had a diagnosis of a serious mental illness and who reported the death of a close friend or family member during a five-year service evaluation project were asked to detail the circumstances that surrounded the death and to rate how the death affected their lives. Key research measures included the self-rated measurement of the impact of the death, the self-rated measurement of the duration of the reported grief, and scores on a psychiatric symptom assessment in the six months after the death. A regression analysis tested the cumulative count of four situational factors-residing with the close friend or family member at the time of the death, the suddenness of the death, having low social support, and having concurrent stressors-as a predictor of severe and prolonged grief.
In the sample of 148 individuals with serious mental illness, 33 (22 percent) reported the death of a close friend or family member as a significant life event that resulted in relatively acute and brief grief (15 individuals, or 10 percent) or severe and prolonged grief (18 individuals, or 12 percent). The regression analysis confirmed that the more situational factors that occurred at the time of the death, the more severe the grief reaction was, irrespective of psychiatric symptomatology.
Mental health services for persons with serious mental illness should begin to incorporate preparation for parental death and bereavement counseling as essential services, and such interventions should approach bereavement as a normal rather than a pathological response to interpersonal loss.
本研究探讨了在普通人群中导致严重悲伤的情境因素,是否能预测被诊断患有严重精神疾病的人群的悲伤严重程度。
在一个为期五年的服务评估项目中,对那些被诊断患有严重精神疾病且报告有亲密朋友或家庭成员死亡的研究参与者,要求他们详细描述死亡时的相关情况,并对死亡对其生活的影响进行评分。主要研究指标包括对死亡影响的自评测量、报告的悲伤持续时间的自评测量,以及死亡后六个月内的精神症状评估得分。回归分析检验了四个情境因素(死亡时与亲密朋友或家庭成员住在一起、死亡的突然性、社会支持低、存在并发应激源)的累计数量,作为严重和长期悲伤的预测指标。
在148名患有严重精神疾病的个体样本中,33人(22%)报告亲密朋友或家庭成员的死亡是一个重大生活事件,导致相对急性和短暂的悲伤(15人,即10%)或严重和长期的悲伤(18人,即12%)。回归分析证实,死亡时出现的情境因素越多,悲伤反应就越严重,与精神症状无关。
针对患有严重精神疾病的人群的心理健康服务,应开始将应对父母死亡的准备和丧亲辅导纳入基本服务,并且此类干预应将丧亲视为对人际丧失的正常而非病理反应。