Adhikari Atin, Sen Moon M, Gupta-Bhattacharya Swati, Chanda Sunirmal
Division of Palynology and Environmental Biology, Department of Botany, Bose Institute, 93/1 Acharya Prafulla Chandra Road, Kolkata (Calcutta) 700 009, India.
Sci Total Environ. 2004 Jun 29;326(1-3):123-41. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2003.12.007.
The information on airborne allergenic fungal flora in rural agricultural areas is largely lacking. Adequate information is not available to the bioaerosol researchers regarding the choice of single versus multiple sampling stations for the monitoring of both viable and non-viable airborne fungi. There is no long-term study estimating the ratios of viable and non-viable fungi in the air and earlier studies did not focus on the fractions of airborne allergenic fungi with respect to the total airborne fungal load. To fill these knowledge gaps, volumetric paired assessments of airborne viable and non-viable fungi were performed in five outdoor sampling stations during two consecutive years in a rural agricultural area of India. Samples were collected at 10-day intervals by the Burkard Personal Slide Sampler and the Andersen Two-Stage Viable Sampler. The data on the concentrations of total and individual fungal types from five stations and 2 different years were analyzed and compared by statistical methods. The allergenicity of the prevalent airborne viable fungi was estimated by the skin-prick tests of >100 rural allergy patients using the antigenic fungal extracts from isolates collected with the Andersen sampler. The ranges of total fungal spore concentration were 82-2365 spores per cubic meter of air (spores/m3) in the first sampling year and 156-2022 spores/m3 in the second sampling year. The concentration ranges of viable fungi were 72-1796 colony-forming units per cubic meter of air (CFU/m3) in the first sampling year and 155-1256 CFU/m3 in the second sampling year. No statistically significant difference was observed between the total spore data of the 2 years, however, the data between five stations showed a significant difference (P<0.0001). No statistically significant difference existed between stations and years with respect to the concentration of viable fungi. When the data of individual allergenic fungal concentrations were compared between stations and years, no statistically significant difference was observed in all cases except for Aspergillus japonicus and Rhizopus nigricans, which showed significant difference in case of stations and years, respectively. The ratios between the total fungal spores collected by the Burkard sampler and the viable fungi collected by the Andersen sampler from all sampling stations ranged between 0.29 and 7.61. The antigenic extracts of eight prevalent viable airborne fungi (A. flavus, A. japonicus, A. fumigatus, Alternaria alternata, Cladosporium cladosporioides, Curvularia pallescens, Fusarium roseum, and R. nigricans) demonstrated >60% positive reactions in the skin prick test. These selected allergenic fungi collectively represented 31.7-63.2% of the total airborne viable fungi in different stations. The study concluded that: (i) a rich fungal airspora existed in the rural study area, (ii) to achieve representative information on the total airborne fungal spores of an area, the monitoring in multiple sampling stations is preferable over a single sampling station; for viable fungi, however, one station can be considered, (iii) the percentage of airborne fungal viability is higher in rural agricultural areas, and (iv) approximately 52% of the viable airborne fungi in the rural study area were allergenic.
农村农业地区空气中致敏真菌菌群的信息严重匮乏。生物气溶胶研究人员无法获得足够的信息,以确定在监测空气中有活力和无活力真菌时,选择单个采样站还是多个采样站。目前尚无长期研究来估计空气中有活力和无活力真菌的比例,早期研究也未关注空气中致敏真菌在总空气真菌负荷中的占比。为填补这些知识空白,在印度一个农村农业地区连续两年对五个室外采样站的空气中有活力和无活力真菌进行了体积配对评估。样本每隔10天通过伯卡德个人载玻片采样器和安德森两级有活力采样器采集。采用统计方法对来自五个采样站和两年的总真菌类型及各真菌类型的浓度数据进行了分析和比较。通过对100多名农村过敏患者进行皮肤点刺试验,使用从安德森采样器采集的分离株的抗原性真菌提取物,估计了空气中普遍存在的有活力真菌的致敏性。在第一个采样年,总真菌孢子浓度范围为每立方米空气82 - 2365个孢子(孢子/立方米),在第二个采样年为156 - 2022个孢子/立方米。有活力真菌的浓度范围在第一个采样年为每立方米空气72 - 1796个菌落形成单位(CFU/立方米),在第二个采样年为155 - 1256 CFU/立方米。两年的总孢子数据之间未观察到统计学上的显著差异,然而,五个采样站的数据显示出显著差异(P<0.0001)。在有活力真菌的浓度方面,采样站和年份之间不存在统计学上的显著差异。当比较各采样站和年份的单个致敏真菌浓度数据时,除日本曲霉和黑根霉外,在所有情况下均未观察到统计学上的显著差异,日本曲霉在采样站方面、黑根霉在年份方面显示出显著差异。从所有采样站来看,伯卡德采样器采集的总真菌孢子与安德森采样器采集的有活力真菌之间的比例在0.29至7.61之间。八种普遍存在的空气中有活力致敏真菌(黄曲霉、日本曲霉、烟曲霉、链格孢、枝孢、苍白弯孢、粉红镰刀菌和黑根霉)的抗原提取物在皮肤点刺试验中显示出>60%的阳性反应。这些选定的致敏真菌在不同采样站的空气中有活力真菌总数中占31.7 - 63.2%。该研究得出结论:(i)农村研究区域存在丰富的空气真菌群落;(ii)为获取某一区域空气中总真菌孢子的代表性信息,多个采样站的监测优于单个采样站;然而,对于有活力真菌,可考虑一个采样站;(iii)农村农业地区空气中真菌的活力百分比更高;(iv)农村研究区域约52%的空气中有活力真菌具有致敏性。