Karlsson A-S, Renström A, Hedrén M, Larsson K
Lung and Allergy Research, National Institute of Environmental Medicine, Karolinska Institutet, Box 287, S-171 77 Stockholm, Sweden.
Allergy. 2004 Jun;59(6):661-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1398-9995.2004.00519.x.
Some schools in Sweden offer allergen avoidance classrooms for allergic children with severe asthma. However, the measures commonly used to achieve a reduction in allergen levels have not been properly evaluated. The aim of the present prospective study was to study whether the levels of airborne cat allergen are altered after introducing feasible intervention measures in classrooms, without interfering with peoples' freedom of choice regarding pet ownership.
Twenty-five classes, including five established allergy prevention classrooms participated in the study during a school year. After one term, six classes underwent a number of intervention measures recommended by the Swedish National Institute of Public Health. Curtains, upholstery and plants were removed, bookshelves were replaced with cupboards and regular cleaning was increased. Airborne dust was collected weekly (32 weeks) using duplicate Petri dishes (n = 1574) and on six occasions using two personal air samplers in each class (n = 264).
Airborne cat allergen levels were showing a similar variability throughout the whole study in all classes. Despite extensive measures in order to reduce allergen exposure, cat allergen levels were unaltered in the six classes after intervention. Allergen levels were not significantly lower in the established allergy prevention classes, compared with the other classes. Cat allergen levels differed, however, significantly between classes with few and many cat owners (P < 0.05).
We conclude that the recommended allergen avoidance measures used in this study did not reduce airborne cat allergen. It seems plausible that measures that fail to reduce allergen levels also fail to influence health status in allergic children but this remains to be shown.
瑞典的一些学校为患有严重哮喘的过敏儿童提供避免接触过敏原的教室。然而,通常用于降低过敏原水平的措施尚未得到妥善评估。本前瞻性研究的目的是研究在教室中引入可行的干预措施后,空气中猫过敏原的水平是否会改变,同时不干扰人们在宠物饲养方面的选择自由。
在一学年期间,25个班级(包括5个已设立的预防过敏教室)参与了该研究。一个学期后,6个班级采取了瑞典国家公共卫生研究所推荐的一系列干预措施。移除了窗帘、室内装饰品和植物,用橱柜取代了书架,并增加了定期清洁。每周(共32周)使用两个重复的培养皿收集空气中的灰尘(n = 1574),并在6个时间点使用每个班级的两个个人空气采样器收集灰尘(n = 264)。
在整个研究过程中,所有班级空气中猫过敏原水平的变化情况相似。尽管采取了广泛的措施以减少过敏原暴露,但干预后6个班级的猫过敏原水平并未改变。与其他班级相比,已设立的预防过敏班级中的过敏原水平并没有显著降低。然而,养猫主人少的班级和养猫主人多的班级之间的猫过敏原水平存在显著差异(P < 0.05)。
我们得出结论,本研究中使用的推荐的避免过敏原措施并未降低空气中的猫过敏原。未能降低过敏原水平的措施似乎也无法影响过敏儿童的健康状况,但这一点仍有待证实。