Li Ying-Chun, Norton Edward C, Dow William H
Department of Health Policy and Management, School of Public Health, Harvard University, Cambridge MA 02138, USA.
Health Serv Res. 2004 Aug;39(4 Pt 1):905-25. doi: 10.1111/j.1475-6773.2004.00264.x.
To test the hypothesis that individuals are more likely to receive a vaccination against influenza or pneumonia as the perceived disease threat increases.
This study uses two different national datasets. Individual-level information about the vaccination rates of 38,768 elderly persons are from the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System, 1993-1998. Information on the combined influenza and pneumonia state mortality rates are measured from the Compressed Mortality File.
Using both cross-sectional and state fixed-effects panel data estimators, we model an individual's probability of having an influenza or pneumococcal vaccination as a function of the lagged state mortality rate. Multiyear lags are specified in order to estimate the duration of the effect of disease mortality on individual vaccination behavior.
Results support our hypothesis that influenza vaccination behavior responds positively to disease mortality, even after a one-year lag. We further find that cross-sectional estimators used in previous work yield downward-biased estimates, although even for our preferred panel data models, the estimated effects are small.
The findings indicate that behavioral demand responses can help to limit infectious disease epidemics, and suggest further research on how public awareness campaigns can mediate this disease threat responsiveness behavior.
检验随着感知到的疾病威胁增加,个体更有可能接种流感或肺炎疫苗这一假设。
本研究使用了两个不同的国家数据集。关于38768名老年人疫苗接种率的个体层面信息来自1993 - 1998年行为风险因素监测系统。流感和肺炎合并州死亡率信息来自压缩死亡率文件。
使用横断面和州固定效应面板数据估计量,我们将个体接种流感或肺炎球菌疫苗的概率建模为滞后州死亡率的函数。指定多年滞后以估计疾病死亡率对个体疫苗接种行为影响的持续时间。
结果支持我们的假设,即流感疫苗接种行为对疾病死亡率有正向反应,即使在一年滞后之后也是如此。我们进一步发现,先前研究中使用的横断面估计量会产生向下偏差的估计,尽管即使对于我们首选的面板数据模型,估计效应也很小。
研究结果表明行为需求反应有助于限制传染病流行,并建议进一步研究公众意识运动如何调节这种对疾病威胁的反应性行为。