Bäckström M, Mjörndal T, Dahlqvist R
Division of Clinical Pharmacology, University Hospital of Umeå, Sweden.
Pharmacoepidemiol Drug Saf. 2004 Jul;13(7):483-7. doi: 10.1002/pds.962.
Adverse drug reactions (ADR) constitute a major problem, both from a medical point of view and as an economical burden. Spontaneous reporting of ADRs is one of the methods for post marketing surveillance of drug safety. Under-reporting can also provide an important obstacle to rapid and relevant signal detection.
To investigate the rate of under-reporting serious ADRs of selected ICD 10 diagnoses.
In order to investigate the under-reporting rate we investigated at five hospitals within the county of Norrbotten in Sweden the total number of diagnosed cases during a period of 5 years (1996-2000) with the following diagnoses: cerebral haemorrhage (I 61.0-I 61.9), pulmonary embolism (I 26.0 and I 26.9), embolism or thrombosis (I 74.0-I 74.9), phlebititis, thrombophlebitits or venous thrombosis (I 80.0-I 80.3, I 80.8 and I 80.9) and portal vein thrombosis and other thrombosis or emboli (I 82.0-I 82.3, I 82.8 and I 82.9). The identity of these patients was obtained through a database search. The patients' case records were then scrutinized by a specially trained nurse and the drugs used at the time of the event were noted. An assessment of the possibility of an ADR was performed using standard WHO causality criteria. Later, database search in the Swedish ADR registry was performed in order to investigate whether these suspected ADRs had been reported to the national authority in Sweden or not.
In total 1349 case records were found and scrutinized. Of these, 107 patients had received drugs that could have been a probable or possible cause to the diagnoses. Of these 92 cases had not been reported and only 15 patients were found in the database, giving an overall under-reporting rate of all ADRs of 86%. The most commonly occurring diagnoses were cerebral haemorrhage followed by venous thrombosis, 545 and 468 respectively. Among those cases that should have been reported according to the existing rules for spontaneous reporting of suspected ADRs the most frequently occurring diagnosis was cerebral haemorrhage (I 61.0) in connection to treatment with anticoagulants.
The rate of spontaneous ADR reporting is very low, also for serious and fatal reactions.
药物不良反应(ADR)无论从医学角度还是经济负担方面来看,都是一个重大问题。药物不良反应的自发报告是药品上市后安全性监测的方法之一。报告不足也会成为快速且相关信号检测的重要障碍。
调查选定的国际疾病分类第十版(ICD 10)诊断中严重药物不良反应的报告不足率。
为调查报告不足率,我们在瑞典北博滕县的五家医院调查了5年期间(1996 - 2000年)诊断为以下疾病的病例总数:脑出血(I 61.0 - I 61.9)、肺栓塞(I 26.0和I 26.9)、栓塞或血栓形成(I 74.0 - I 74.9)、静脉炎、血栓性静脉炎或静脉血栓形成(I 80.0 - I 80.3、I 80.8和I 80.9)以及门静脉血栓形成和其他血栓形成或栓塞(I 82.0 - I 82.3、I 82.8和I 82.9)。通过数据库搜索获取这些患者的身份信息。然后由一名经过专门培训的护士仔细审查患者的病历,并记录事件发生时使用的药物。使用世界卫生组织标准因果关系标准对药物不良反应的可能性进行评估。之后,在瑞典药物不良反应登记处进行数据库搜索,以调查这些疑似药物不良反应是否已报告给瑞典国家当局。
总共找到并审查了1349份病历。其中,107名患者接受了可能是诊断病因的药物。在这些患者中,92例未报告,仅在数据库中发现15例患者,所有药物不良反应的总体报告不足率为86%。最常见的诊断是脑出血,其次是静脉血栓形成,分别为545例和468例。在那些根据现有疑似药物不良反应自发报告规则应报告的病例中,最常见的诊断是与抗凝治疗相关的脑出血(I 61.0)。
药物不良反应的自发报告率非常低,对于严重和致命反应亦是如此。