Lai C H, Oshima K, Slots J, Listgarten M A
University of Pennsylvania School of Dental Medicine, Department of Periodontics, Philadelphia.
J Periodontal Res. 1992 Jan;27(1):8-14. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0765.1992.tb02079.x.
Wolinella recta has been associated with adult periodontitis, but its role in the disease remains uncertain. This report clarifies the distribution of W. recta in periodontally healthy and diseased subjects, and treated patients with recurrent disease. A specific polyclonal rabbit antiserum against W. recta strain 372 was used for indirect immunofluorescence localization of W. recta in dental plaque from untreated and treated patients. Supragingival plaque was collected from 15 periodontally healthy individuals (H), 10 adults with mild gingivitis (G1), 8 with severe gingivitis (G2) and 15 with periodontitis (AP). Subgingival samples from 23 diseased sites (G2 and AP) were examined as well. There was a significant difference (p = 0.000) between the proportions of W. recta in subgingival (4.4%) vs. supragingival (0.3%) plaque samples from AP. A significant difference (p = 0.000) in W. recta proportions was also detected between subgingival plaque samples of AP (4.4%) vs. G2 (1.2%). No significant difference in the mean % of W. recta was found between supragingival plaque of AP (0.3%) and G2 (0%), and samples of G1 (0.01%) and H (0.1%). In a separate study, 85 adults previously treated for moderate to severe adult periodontitis were monitored over a 12-month period for evidence of disease recurrence. Recurrent disease was detected at 32 sites in 18 subjects. Of these, 20 sites in 13 subjects were positive for W. recta. With subjects as the experimental unit, a significant increase in the proportions of W. recta was found at sites with recurrent disease (3.12%) as compared to stable, paired control sites (0.24%), but only when sites with breakdown and positive for W. recta were compared with their controls. These results indicate that W. recta is associated with some, but not all sites with advanced adult periodontitis. The association of W. recta with gingivitis was not statistically significant.
直肠沃氏菌与成人牙周炎有关,但其在该疾病中的作用仍不确定。本报告阐明了直肠沃氏菌在牙周健康和患病个体以及复发性疾病患者中的分布情况。使用针对直肠沃氏菌菌株372的特异性兔多克隆抗血清,通过间接免疫荧光法对未治疗和已治疗患者牙菌斑中的直肠沃氏菌进行定位。从15名牙周健康个体(H)、10名轻度牙龈炎成人(G1)、8名重度牙龈炎患者(G2)和15名牙周炎患者(AP)收集龈上菌斑。还检查了23个患病部位(G2和AP)的龈下样本。在AP患者的龈下菌斑样本(4.4%)和龈上菌斑样本(0.3%)中,直肠沃氏菌比例存在显著差异(p = 0.000)。在AP患者的龈下菌斑样本(4.4%)和G2患者的龈下菌斑样本(1.2%)之间,直肠沃氏菌比例也检测到显著差异(p = 0.000)。在AP患者的龈上菌斑(0.3%)与G2患者的龈上菌斑(0%)、G1患者的样本(0.01%)和H患者的样本(0.1%)之间,直肠沃氏菌的平均百分比未发现显著差异。在另一项研究中,对85名先前接受过中度至重度成人牙周炎治疗的成年人进行了为期12个月的疾病复发监测。在18名受试者的32个部位检测到疾病复发。其中,13名受试者的20个部位直肠沃氏菌呈阳性。以受试者作为实验单位,与稳定的配对对照部位(0.24%)相比,复发疾病部位的直肠沃氏菌比例显著增加(3.12%),但仅当出现病变且直肠沃氏菌呈阳性的部位与其对照部位进行比较时。这些结果表明,直肠沃氏菌与部分而非所有晚期成人牙周炎部位有关。直肠沃氏菌与牙龈炎的关联无统计学意义。