Marx Jonathan I, Solomon Jennifer Crew, Miller Lee Q
Department of Sociology and Anthropology, Winthrop University, 701 Oakland Ave., Rock Hill, SC 29733, USA.
J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci. 2004 Sep;59(5):S274-80. doi: 10.1093/geronb/59.5.s274.
This qualitative study examines the "final gift exchange" process by which older adults give cherished possessions in return for lasting appreciation.
We interviewed 54 middle- and upper-middle-class people (39 women) aged 50-90 who had to dispose of personal objects when moving to smaller residences.
We used Goffman's spiraling strategy in our analysis of people's reports of disposing of personal possessions. We identified three salient dimensions (family, economy, and self) of this process and created a heuristic describing eight ideal-type gift exchange scenarios by categorizing objects as valued or not valued by family and the economy as well as being an important aspect of the gift giver's material self.
By applying the heuristic, we observed that a lack of shared definitions of the meaning and value of objects created dilemmas in disposing of personal objects, particularly those connected to a person's material self. We also offer suggestions for making the process go more smoothly, such as inquiring about the preferences of others and telling stories associated with objects to create shared definitions of the objects' significance to the giver and/or to family history.
本定性研究考察了老年人进行“最终礼物交换”的过程,即通过赠送珍贵物品以换取长久的感激之情。
我们采访了54名年龄在50至90岁之间的中上层阶级人士(39名女性),他们在搬入较小住所时不得不处理个人物品。
在分析人们处理个人物品的报告时,我们运用了戈夫曼的螺旋策略。我们确定了这一过程的三个显著维度(家庭、经济和自我),并通过将物品分类为家庭和经济所重视或不重视的,以及作为礼物赠送者物质自我的一个重要方面,创建了一种启发式方法,描述了八种理想类型的礼物交换场景。
通过应用这种启发式方法,我们观察到对物品的意义和价值缺乏共同定义会在处理个人物品时造成困境,尤其是那些与个人物质自我相关的物品。我们还提出了一些使这个过程更顺利进行的建议,比如询问他人的偏好,讲述与物品相关的故事,以创建对物品对赠送者和/或家族历史的重要性的共同定义。