Henderson R C, Kemp G J, Campion E R
University of North Carolina School of Medicine, Chapel Hill 27599-7055.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1992 Feb;74(2):211-8.
This study compared the bone-mineral density in the proximal part of the femur and the flexion and extension strength of the knee in the fractured and the non-fractured limbs after an uncomplicated fracture of the tibia or femur in children. Thirty-eight children, whose ages ranged from two to fifteen years at the time of the injury, were evaluated at an average of 2.3 years after the injury. The mean difference in bone-mineral density between the fractured and non-fractured limbs was 3.3 per cent (p = 0.004). There was no significant difference between the bone-mineral density of the limbs that had been immobilized for less than four weeks and that of the contralateral, non-fractured limbs. However, the mean difference between the bone-mineral density of the limbs that had been immobilized for more than eight weeks and that of the contralateral limbs was 4.3 per cent (p = 0.006). There was little or no relationship between the time since the injury and the difference in bone-mineral density between the two limbs of the patient at the intervals of follow-up that were studied. No residual weakness in flexion and extension of the knee was detected, and no relationship was established between the limb-to-limb differences in strength and the limb-to-limb differences in bone-mineral density. The residual bone-mineral deficit was found to be minimum after an uncomplicated fracture. This difference, while statistically significant, is unlikely to be clinically important in the long term. However, the fact that there was a deficit raises a potential concern for children who have more severe or repeated injuries.
本研究比较了儿童胫腓骨或股骨单纯性骨折后,伤肢与未伤肢股骨近端的骨密度以及膝关节的屈伸力量。38名受伤时年龄在2至15岁之间的儿童,在受伤后平均2.3年接受了评估。伤肢与未伤肢的骨密度平均差异为3.3%(p = 0.004)。固定时间少于四周的肢体与对侧未受伤肢体的骨密度之间无显著差异。然而,固定时间超过八周的肢体与对侧肢体的骨密度平均差异为4.3%(p = 0.006)。在所研究的随访间隔中,受伤时间与患者两肢体骨密度差异之间几乎没有或没有关系。未检测到膝关节屈伸的残余无力,并且力量的肢体间差异与骨密度的肢体间差异之间未建立关系。发现单纯性骨折后的残余骨密度缺损最小。这种差异虽然具有统计学意义,但从长期来看在临床上不太可能具有重要意义。然而,存在骨密度缺损这一事实对那些有更严重或反复受伤的儿童来说是一个潜在的担忧。