Linggood R M, Chapman P H
Harvard Medical School, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston.
J Neurooncol. 1992 Jan;12(1):85-91. doi: 10.1007/BF00172460.
From 1972-1985, 30 patients with pineal area tumor have been treated with combinations of surgery and irradiation, no patient receiving chemotherapy as a primary recommendation. Patients ranged between 3 and 69 years of age, 18 were male and 12 female. In 18 patients a tissue diagnosis was made initially, 14 patients required shunts before definitive management and in 8 of the 14 tissue diagnosis was made at the same time. Eight patients had no surgical intervention at any time. Patients who have received irradiation have had whole brain irradiation, local field irradiation, or craniospinal irradiation. Two elderly patients died rapidly of their malignant processes before definitive treatment could be given. Only one patient with a non neoplastic lesion was seen. This was a bleed from an AVM with no underlying tumor. One patient with a pineocytoma was not irradiated. Overall, two-thirds of our patients are alive 5 to 15 years after treatment. There has been no surgical mortality and minimal morbidity from biopsy. Late effects of treatment include one patient with mild hearing loss and three patients with endocrinopathies amenable to medical treatment. We believe that tissue diagnosis allows optimal field design and dose recommendations to be made by the radiotherapist in addition to defining prognosis. In our experience, endodermal sinus tumor and pineoblastoma are highly malignant, and in view of their poor prognosis with conventional management consideration of more radical treatment with a possible role for chemotherapy is suggested.
1972年至1985年期间,30例松果体区肿瘤患者接受了手术和放疗联合治疗,无一例患者作为主要推荐接受化疗。患者年龄在3岁至69岁之间,男性18例,女性12例。18例患者最初进行了组织诊断,14例患者在明确治疗前需要进行分流术,其中8例在分流术时同时进行了组织诊断。8例患者在任何时候都未接受手术干预。接受放疗的患者接受了全脑放疗、局部野放疗或全脑脊髓放疗。2例老年患者在能够进行明确治疗之前因恶性肿瘤迅速死亡。仅见1例非肿瘤性病变患者,这是一例无潜在肿瘤的动静脉畸形出血。1例松果体细胞瘤患者未接受放疗。总体而言,我们的患者中有三分之二在治疗后5至15年仍存活。活检无手术死亡且并发症极少。治疗的晚期效应包括1例轻度听力丧失患者和3例可通过药物治疗的内分泌病患者。我们认为,组织诊断除了能确定预后外,还能让放疗科医生做出最佳的照射野设计和剂量建议。根据我们的经验,内胚窦瘤和松果体母细胞瘤具有高度恶性,鉴于其采用传统治疗预后较差,建议考虑采用更积极的治疗方法,化疗可能发挥作用。