Maizels Morris, Blumenfeld Andrew, Burchette Raoul
Kaiser Permanente, Family Practice, Woodland Hills, CA, USA.
Headache. 2004 Oct;44(9):885-90. doi: 10.1111/j.1526-4610.2004.04170.x.
To determine the efficacy for migraine prophylaxis of a compound containing a combination of riboflavin, magnesium, and feverfew.
Previous studies of magnesium and feverfew for migraine prophylaxis have found conflicting results, and there has been only a single placebo-controlled trial of riboflavin.
DESIGN/METHODS: Randomized double-blind placebo-controlled trial of a compound providing a daily dose of riboflavin 400 mg, magnesium 300 mg, and feverfew 100 mg. The placebo contained 25 mg riboflavin. The study included a 1-month run-in phase and 3-month trial. The protocol allowed for 120 patients to be randomized, with a preplanned interim analysis of the data after 48 patients had completed the trial.
Forty-nine patients completed the 3-month trial. For the primary outcome measure, a 50% or greater reduction in migraines, there was no difference between active and "placebo" groups, achieved by 10 (42%) and 11 (44%), respectively (P=.87). Similarly, there was no significant difference in secondary outcome measures, for active versus placebo groups, respectively: 50% or greater reduction in migraine days (33% and 40%, P=.63); or change in mean number of migraines, migraine days, migraine index, or triptan doses. Compared to baseline, however, both groups showed a significant reduction in number of migraines, migraine days, and migraine index. This effect exceeds that reported for placebo agents in previous migraine trials.
Riboflavin 25 mg showed an effect comparable to a combination of riboflavin 400 mg, magnesium 300 mg, and feverfew 100 mg. The placebo response exceeds that reported for any other placebo in trials of migraine prophylaxis, and suggests that riboflavin 25 mg may be an active comparator. There is at present conflicting scientific evidence with regard to the efficacy of these compounds for migraine prophylaxis.
确定一种含有核黄素、镁和小白菊的化合物预防偏头痛的疗效。
先前关于镁和小白菊预防偏头痛的研究结果相互矛盾,而核黄素仅有一项安慰剂对照试验。
设计/方法:对一种每日提供400毫克核黄素、300毫克镁和100毫克小白菊的化合物进行随机双盲安慰剂对照试验。安慰剂含有25毫克核黄素。该研究包括1个月的导入期和3个月的试验期。研究方案允许120名患者随机分组,在48名患者完成试验后对数据进行预先计划的中期分析。
49名患者完成了3个月的试验。对于主要结局指标,即偏头痛减少50%或更多,活性组和“安慰剂”组之间没有差异,分别有10名(42%)和11名(44%)达到这一效果(P = 0.87)。同样,活性组与安慰剂组在次要结局指标上也没有显著差异,分别为:偏头痛天数减少50%或更多(33%和40%,P = 0.63);或偏头痛平均发作次数、偏头痛天数、偏头痛指数或曲坦类药物剂量的变化。然而,与基线相比,两组的偏头痛发作次数、偏头痛天数和偏头痛指数均显著减少。这一效果超过了先前偏头痛试验中报道的安慰剂药物的效果。
25毫克核黄素显示出与400毫克核黄素、300毫克镁和100毫克小白菊的组合相当的效果。安慰剂反应超过了偏头痛预防试验中报道的任何其他安慰剂的反应,表明25毫克核黄素可能是一种有效的对照物。目前关于这些化合物预防偏头痛的疗效存在相互矛盾的科学证据。