Silverman Jeffrey A, Barrett Jon, Callum Jeannie L
Department of Hematology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Obstet Gynecol. 2004 Nov;104(5 Pt 1):1000-4. doi: 10.1097/01.AOG.0000142710.16254.21.
Despite published guidelines, numerous studies have consistently shown that a significant proportion of red blood cell (RBC) transfusions are unnecessary. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the reasons for and the appropriateness of RBC transfusions in the peripartum patient.
We reviewed all RBC transfusions given to peripartum inpatients at Sunnybrook and Women's College Health Sciences Centre in Toronto, Ontario, Canada between April 1994 and July 2002. Appropriateness of RBC transfusion was ascertained using current hospital transfusion guidelines.
We identified 33,795 obstetrics-related admissions. In 218 admissions (0.65% of all admissions), an RBC transfusion was given to 216 women. There were 83 vaginal deliveries, 94 deliveries by cesarean, and 42 operations (for ectopic pregnancies or dilatation and curettage). A total of 779 RBC units were transfused (median, 2 units per woman; range, 1-32), most commonly for postpartum bleeding (34% of cases). There were 16 adverse events from transfusion recorded. According to guidelines, 248 of the transfused RBC units (32%) were not appropriate. In addition, in 24 patients (11%) the mean corpuscular volume on admission to the hospital for delivery was less than or equal to 80 fL.
A significant proportion of RBC transfusions given to peripartum women are inappropriate. Educational programs that promote adherence to transfusion guidelines might help reduce exposure to RBC transfusion. Aggressive oral and intravenous iron therapy might have prevented transfusion in 11% of the women in the cohort who were possibly iron deficient.
尽管有已发布的指南,但众多研究一直表明,相当一部分红细胞(RBC)输血是不必要的。本研究的目的是评估围产期患者红细胞输血的原因及合理性。
我们回顾了1994年4月至2002年7月期间在加拿大多伦多桑尼布鲁克与女子学院健康科学中心给予围产期住院患者的所有红细胞输血情况。使用当前医院输血指南确定红细胞输血的合理性。
我们确定了33795例与产科相关的入院病例。在218例入院病例(占所有入院病例的0.65%)中,对216名女性进行了红细胞输血。其中有83例阴道分娩、94例剖宫产以及42例手术(用于异位妊娠或刮宫术)。总共输注了779个红细胞单位(中位数为每位女性2个单位;范围为1 - 32个单位),最常见的原因是产后出血(占病例的34%)。记录到16例输血相关不良事件。根据指南,所输注的红细胞单位中有248个(32%)是不合理的。此外,在24名患者(11%)中,入院分娩时的平均红细胞体积小于或等于80 fL。
给予围产期女性的红细胞输血中有很大一部分是不合理的。促进遵守输血指南的教育项目可能有助于减少红细胞输血的暴露。积极的口服和静脉铁剂治疗可能会预防该队列中11%可能缺铁女性的输血需求。