McManus Samuel P, Somani Sunil, Harris J Milton, McGill R Andrew
Department of Chemistry, The University of Alabama in Huntsville, Huntsville, AL 35899, USA.
J Org Chem. 2004 Dec 10;69(25):8865-73. doi: 10.1021/jo049798l.
Solvolysis/dehydrohalogenation rates of 2-chloro-2-methyladamantane (CMA) in 15 hydrogen-bond acidic and/or basic solvents are studied. The rates of reaction in these solvents have been correlated with the solvation equation developed by Kamlet, Abraham, and Taft. The linear solvation energy relationship (LSER) derived from this study is given by the following equation: log k = -5.409 + 2.219 + 2.505alpha(1) - 1.823beta(1) where , alpha(1), and beta(1) are the solvation parameters that measure the solvent dipolarity/polarizability, hydrogen-bond acidity (electrophilicity), and hydrogen-bond basicity (nucleophilicity). A high correlation coefficient (r = 0.996, SD = 0.191) was achieved. The cavity term, which includes the Hildebrand parameter for solvent cohesive energy density, delta(H), was not found to be statistically significant for this reaction substrate. The resulting equation allows calculated rates of reaction in other solvents and provides insight into the reaction pathway. In a previously reported correlation for another tertiary chloride, tert-butyl chloride (TBC), the coefficients for alpha(1) and are significantly larger and the coefficient for is statistically significant. In addition, the coefficient for beta(1) in the TBC correlation is positive, rather than negative, indicating that the transition states for TBC and CMA are significantly different. These results demonstrate why the uses of simple solvolytic correlation methods may be invalid even for comparisons of similar type substrates, e.g., tertiary chlorides. Also, these results provide confidence in the use of multiple linear regression analysis for predicting solvolytic rates in additional solvents.
研究了2-氯-2-甲基金刚烷(CMA)在15种氢键酸性和/或碱性溶剂中的溶剂解/脱卤化氢速率。这些溶剂中的反应速率已与Kamlet、Abraham和Taft开发的溶剂化方程相关联。本研究得出的线性溶剂化能关系(LSER)由以下方程给出:log k = -5.409 + 2.219 + 2.505α(1) - 1.823β(1),其中α(1)和β(1)是衡量溶剂偶极矩/极化率、氢键酸度(亲电性)和氢键碱度(亲核性)的溶剂化参数。获得了较高的相关系数(r = 0.996,SD = 0.191)。对于该反应底物,未发现包含溶剂内聚能密度的Hildebrand参数δ(H)的空穴项具有统计学意义。所得方程可用于计算其他溶剂中的反应速率,并深入了解反应途径。在先前报道的另一种叔氯化合物叔丁基氯(TBC)的相关性中,α(1)的系数显著更大,且具有统计学意义。此外,TBC相关性中β(1)的系数为正,而非负,这表明TBC和CMA的过渡态有显著差异。这些结果表明,即使对于类似类型底物(如叔氯化合物)的比较,简单的溶剂解相关方法也可能无效。此外,这些结果为使用多元线性回归分析预测其他溶剂中的溶剂解速率提供了信心。