McCartan B E, Shanley D B
Department of Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine and Oral Pathology, School of Dental Science, Trinity College Dublin.
Br Dent J. 2005 Apr 9;198(7):423-5. doi: 10.1038/sj.bdj.4812196.
To investigate the policies and practices of European dental schools in relation to smoking as a ten-year follow-up.
A postal survey questionnaire.
European dental schools in 2003.
Two hundred and one European dental schools were identified from the DentEd database. A postal questionnaire was sent to each with up to three follow-up letters to non-responders.
Results were tabulated and compared with the previous study (1993).
The effective response rate (allowing for errors in the database) was 149 of 199 schools (72%). Eighty schools (59%) had written tobacco policies, 132 (92%) banned smoking in clinical areas, 127 (89%) in non-clinical areas and 122 (85%) in public access areas. One hundred and seven (76%) expected students to take tobacco histories from all patients, while 79 (69%) and 100 (70%) respectively taught students anti-smoking advice and expected them to give such advice. The number of schools teaching the role of tobacco in oral cancer aetiology was 133 (93%), in periodontal disease was 135 (94%) and in osseointegrated implant failure was 127 (91%). There was considerable regional variation between northern, southern and eastern Europe. Direct comparison of the responses of the 78 schools that replied in both 1993 and 2003 showed some improvements in most of their policies and practices. However, there was some deterioration in the practices of southern European schools.
While improvements were seen in the practices of most schools, comparison with recent US data suggests that European schools lag behind. However, self-selection of respondents may have introduced bias into the results.
作为一项为期十年的随访研究,调查欧洲牙科学校关于吸烟的政策和做法。
邮寄调查问卷。
2003年的欧洲牙科学校。
从DentEd数据库中识别出201所欧洲牙科学校。向每所学校发送一份邮寄问卷,对未回复者最多发送三封跟进信函。
将结果制成表格,并与之前的研究(1993年)进行比较。
有效回复率(考虑数据库中的错误)为199所学校中的149所(72%)。80所学校(59%)制定了书面烟草政策,132所(92%)在临床区域禁止吸烟,127所(89%)在非临床区域禁止吸烟,122所(85%)在公共区域禁止吸烟。107所(76%)期望学生询问所有患者的吸烟史,而分别有79所(69%)和100所(70%)教授学生戒烟建议,并期望他们提供此类建议。教授烟草在口腔癌病因中作用的学校有133所(93%),教授在牙周病中作用的有135所(94%),教授在骨结合种植失败中作用的有127所(91%)。北欧、南欧和东欧之间存在相当大的地区差异。对1993年和2003年都回复的78所学校的回复进行直接比较发现,它们的大多数政策和做法都有一些改进。然而,南欧学校的做法出现了一些恶化。
虽然大多数学校的做法有所改进,但与美国近期数据相比表明欧洲学校仍落后。然而,受访者的自我选择可能给结果带来了偏差。