Lim Chae-Hun, Jee Won-Hee, Son Byung Chul, Kim Dong-Hyun, Ha Kee-Yong, Park Chun-Kun
Department of Radiology, Kangnam St. Mary's Hospital, The Catholic University of Korea, 505 Banpo-dong, Seocho-gu, 137-701 Seoul, Korea.
Eur J Radiol. 2005 Jun;54(3):431-7. doi: 10.1016/j.ejrad.2004.05.014.
To correlate MR and CT discography findings with pain response at provocative discography in patients with discogenic back pain.
Forty-seven patients aged 25-54 years who underwent MR imaging and subsequent CT discography (97 discs) were included in this study. MR images were retrospectively evaluated regarding disc degeneration, endplate abnormalities, facet joint osteoarthritis, and high intensity zone. During discography concordant pain was regarded as positive, whereas discordant pain and no pain were regarded as negative. MR and CT discographic findings were analyzed on the base of concordant pain using the Chi-square test.
: Concordant pain was significantly common in the following (P < 0.05): grade 4 or 5 disc degeneration [88% (30/34) in concordant pain versus 48% (30/63) in discordant pain and no pain], high intensity zone [56% (19/34) versus 30% (19/63)], combination of above two findings [53% (18/34) versus 25% (16/63)], fissured and ruptured disc at discogram [94% (32/34) versus 57% (36/63)], and contrast beyond inner annulus at CT discogram [97% (33/34) versus 57% (36/63)].
Typical MR findings with concordant pain at discography include grade 4 or 5 disc degeneration and presence of a high intensity zone. Typical CT discography findings with concordant pain were fissured/ruptured discs and contrast extending into/beyond the outer annulus on CT.
探讨椎间盘源性下腰痛患者在激发性椎间盘造影时,磁共振成像(MR)和CT椎间盘造影结果与疼痛反应之间的相关性。
本研究纳入了47例年龄在25 - 54岁之间,接受过MR成像及后续CT椎间盘造影(共97个椎间盘)的患者。对MR图像进行回顾性评估,观察椎间盘退变、终板异常、小关节骨关节炎及高信号区情况。在椎间盘造影过程中,将一致性疼痛视为阳性,不一致性疼痛和无疼痛视为阴性。采用卡方检验,基于一致性疼痛对MR和CT椎间盘造影结果进行分析。
在以下情况中,一致性疼痛明显更常见(P < 0.05):4级或5级椎间盘退变[一致性疼痛组为88%(30/34),不一致性疼痛和无疼痛组为48%(30/63)]、高信号区[56%(19/34)对30%(19/63)]、上述两种情况同时存在[53%(18/34)对25%(16/63)]、椎间盘造影时椎间盘出现裂隙和破裂[94%(32/34)对57%(36/63)]以及CT椎间盘造影时对比剂超出椎间盘内纤维环[97%(33/34)对57%(36/63)]。
椎间盘造影时出现一致性疼痛的典型MR表现包括4级或5级椎间盘退变以及高信号区的存在。椎间盘造影时出现一致性疼痛的典型CT表现为椎间盘裂隙/破裂以及CT上对比剂延伸至椎间盘外纤维环内/外。