Agarwal R, Aggarwal A N, Gupta D, Behera D, Jindal S K
Department of Pulmonary Medicine, Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh 160012, India.
Emerg Med J. 2005 Jun;22(6):397-9. doi: 10.1136/emj.2004.020727.
The objective of this study was to evaluate the effects of two different dosage protocols on the outcome of patients with severe neurotoxic snake envenoming, using a retrospective analysis of patients admitted with a diagnosis of severe neurotoxic snake bite over a 4 year period. In the study, 55 snake bite victims requiring ventilatory support for severe neurotoxic envenoming received either 150 ml of polyvalent snake antivenom (SAV) (low dose SAV group, n = 28) or 100 ml of SAV at presentation followed by 100 ml every 6 hours until recovery of neurological manifestations (high dose group, n = 27). The median dose of SAV in the high dose group was 600 ml (range 300 to 1600). The duration of mechanical ventilation in the low dose group (median 47.5 hours; range 14 to 248) was similar to that in the high dose group (median 44 hours; range 6 to 400). The mean (SD) duration of intensive care unit stay was similar in the two groups. There were three deaths in the high dose group; two patients in the low dose group had neurological sequelae. All other patients improved, had no residual neurological deficit, and were discharged. We conclude that there is no difference between a protocol using lower doses of SAV and one with higher doses in the management of patients with severe neurotoxic snake envenoming.
本研究的目的是通过对4年间因严重神经毒性蛇咬伤入院患者的回顾性分析,评估两种不同剂量方案对严重神经毒性蛇伤患者治疗结果的影响。在该研究中,55名因严重神经毒性蛇伤需要通气支持的蛇咬伤受害者,要么接受150毫升多价蛇抗毒血清(SAV)(低剂量SAV组,n = 28),要么在就诊时接受100毫升SAV,随后每6小时接受100毫升,直至神经症状恢复(高剂量组,n = 27)。高剂量组SAV的中位剂量为600毫升(范围300至1600)。低剂量组机械通气的持续时间(中位数47.5小时;范围14至248)与高剂量组(中位数44小时;范围6至400)相似。两组重症监护病房住院的平均(标准差)时间相似。高剂量组有3例死亡;低剂量组有2例患者出现神经后遗症。所有其他患者病情好转,无残留神经功能缺损,并已出院。我们得出结论,在严重神经毒性蛇伤患者的治疗中,使用较低剂量SAV的方案与使用较高剂量SAV的方案之间没有差异。