Sarin Krishna, Dutta Tarun Kumar, Vinod K V
Department of General Medicine, Jawaharlal Institute of Postgraduate Medical Education & Research, Puducherry, India.
Indian J Med Res. 2017 Jan;145(1):58-62. doi: 10.4103/ijmr.IJMR_1319_14.
BACKGROUND & OBJECTIVES: The optimal anti-snake venom (ASV) dose required to treat neurotoxic snake envenomation is not known. Low-dose ASV (national protocol: maximum dose 200 ml) may be as efficacious as the conventional regimen (100 ml six hourly till all symptoms disappear), but a direct comparison of the regimens is not available. The aim of this study was to test the efficacy of low-dose ASV regimen against the conventional high-dose regimen.
The clinical profile of 51 patients with neurotoxic snake envenomation was studied. Patients were treated with either the national protocol or the conventional protocol for ASV administration. The time to complete recovery of symptoms, duration of mechanical ventilation and total dose of ASV were compared.
More patients were females (28 vs. 23) bitten in the early morning hours (2400-0600 h). Thirty nine of 51 (76.4%) patients required mechanical ventilation. In terms of progression of neuroparalysis, time to complete resolution of ptosis and occurrence of VAP and ASV reactions, there was no difference. Duration of mechanical ventilation was less with the national protocol (24 vs. 43.5 h). Significantly less amount of ASV was used with the national protocol (224 vs. 982 ml) per patient. There were no mortality or permanent neurological sequelae with either regimen.
INTERPRETATION & CONCLUSIONS: In this preliminary study, it was found that the national ASV protocol was as effective as the conventional regimen for neurotoxic snake bites. However, the findings need to be tested in a larger randomized controlled trial for definitive conclusions.
治疗神经毒性蛇咬伤所需的最佳抗蛇毒血清(ASV)剂量尚不清楚。低剂量ASV(国家方案:最大剂量200毫升)可能与传统方案(每6小时100毫升,直至所有症状消失)同样有效,但尚无这两种方案的直接比较。本研究的目的是测试低剂量ASV方案与传统高剂量方案的疗效。
研究了51例神经毒性蛇咬伤患者的临床资料。患者接受国家方案或传统方案的ASV给药治疗。比较症状完全恢复的时间、机械通气时间和ASV总剂量。
女性患者更多(28例对23例),咬伤多发生在清晨(0点至6点)。51例患者中有39例(76.4%)需要机械通气。在神经麻痹进展、上睑下垂完全消退时间、呼吸机相关性肺炎(VAP)和ASV反应的发生方面,两种方案没有差异。国家方案的机械通气时间较短(24小时对43.5小时)。每位患者使用的ASV量国家方案明显较少(224毫升对982毫升)。两种方案均无死亡或永久性神经后遗症。
在这项初步研究中,发现国家ASV方案对神经毒性蛇咬伤的疗效与传统方案相同。然而,这些发现需要在更大规模的随机对照试验中进行验证,以得出明确结论。