Simon J G, De Boer J B, Joung I M A, Bosma H, Mackenbach J P
Department of Public Health, Erasmus University Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Eur J Public Health. 2005 Apr;15(2):200-8. doi: 10.1093/eurpub/cki102.
The single-item measure on self-assessed health has been widely used, as it presents researchers with a summary of an individual's general state of health. A qualitative study was initiated to find out which particular aspects are included in health self-assessments; which aspects do people consider when answering the question 'How is your health in general?'. Subgroup differences were studied with respect to gender, age, health status and health assessment.
Qualitative study with stratification by background characteristic, health status and health assessment (n=40).
Almost 80% of the participants referred to one or more physical aspects (chronic illness, physical problems, medical treatment, age-related complaints, prognosis, bodily mechanics, and resilience). However, when assessing their health, participants also include aspects that go beyond the physical dimension of health. In total, 80 percent of the participants-whether or not in addition to physical aspects-referred to other health dimensions. Besides physical aspects, participants considered the extent to which they are able to perform (functional dimension -28%), the extent to which they adapted to, or their attitude towards an existing illness (coping dimension -28%), and simply the way they feel (wellbeing dimension -20%). In this study, health behaviour or lifestyle factors (behavioural dimension -3%) proved to be relatively unimportant in health self-assessments.
Self-assessed health proved to be a multidimensional concept. For most part, subgroup differences in self-assessed health could be attributed to experience with ill health: being relatively inexperienced with health problems versus having a history of health problems.
自我评估健康的单项测量方法已被广泛使用,因为它为研究人员提供了个人总体健康状况的总结。开展了一项定性研究,以找出健康自我评估中包含哪些具体方面;人们在回答“你的总体健康状况如何?”这个问题时会考虑哪些方面。研究了性别、年龄、健康状况和健康评估方面的亚组差异。
按背景特征、健康状况和健康评估进行分层的定性研究(n = 40)。
近80%的参与者提到了一个或多个身体方面(慢性病、身体问题、医疗治疗、与年龄相关的不适、预后、身体机能和恢复力)。然而,在评估自己的健康状况时,参与者还包括了健康身体维度之外的方面。总共有80%的参与者——无论是否除了身体方面之外——提到了其他健康维度。除身体方面外,参与者还考虑了他们的表现能力(功能维度——28%)、他们对现有疾病的适应程度或态度(应对维度——28%)以及他们的感受方式(幸福感维度——20%)。在这项研究中,健康行为或生活方式因素(行为维度——3%)在健康自我评估中被证明相对不重要。
自我评估健康被证明是一个多维概念。在很大程度上,自我评估健康的亚组差异可归因于健康不佳的经历:相对没有健康问题经历与有健康问题病史。