Gayet-Ageron Angèle, Amamra Nassira, Ringa Virginie, Tainturier Valérie, Berr Claudine, Clavel-Chapelon Françoise, Delcourt Cécile, Delmas Pierre D, Ducimetière Pierre, Schott Anne-Marie
Département d'Information Médicale des Hospices Civils de Lyon, 162 avenue Lacassagne, 69003 Lyon, France.
Maturitas. 2005 Nov-Dec;52(3-4):296-305. doi: 10.1016/j.maturitas.2005.05.002. Epub 2005 Jun 13.
To estimate the number of women aged 50-69 years treated by hormone therapy (HT) in France before Women's Health Initiative's (WHI) results and to evaluate the potential decrease of HT prescriptions since the publication of WHI clinical trial.
We used data from eight computerized databases of French cohort studies providing information on HT and constituted by women aged over 50 years living in metropolitan France. From these, we used direct standardization on the French population to estimate the prevalence of HT users across 5 years age groups. Data from the National Health Insurance Agency on two time-periods November 2002-January 2003 and November 2003-January 2004 were used to evaluate the evolution of HT prescriptions since WHI's publication among women aged 50-69 years living in the Rhône-Alpes region.
The crude prevalence of HT users among women aged 50-69 years was 52.3% (51.8-52.8) and corresponds to a standardized prevalence of 35.7% (35.1-36.4), that is about 2.56 (2.51-2.59) million women. Standardized prevalence was the highest in 50-54 years age group then it decreased significantly across the older age groups (p<10(-6)). HT reimbursements decreased significantly between the two studied time-periods in the Rhône-Alpes region (p<10(-6)) from -14 to -45%, depending on the considered age groups (65-69 or 50-54 years).
Although WHI results have been criticized by French professional societies based on the fact that treatments used were different in France--mainly transdermal estrogens--and that French postmenopausal women were at lower vascular risk than those of the WHI, the release of this study had effect on the prescription before the French regulatory agency (AFSSAPS) edited limiting recommendations for HT prescription. Further efforts have to be made to collect systematically information on preventive treatments used at menopause followed by evaluation studies.
估计在妇女健康倡议(WHI)结果公布之前法国50 - 69岁接受激素治疗(HT)的女性人数,并评估自WHI临床试验发表以来HT处方的潜在减少情况。
我们使用了来自法国队列研究的八个计算机化数据库的数据,这些数据库提供了关于HT的信息,由居住在法国本土的50岁以上女性组成。据此,我们对法国人口进行直接标准化,以估计5岁年龄组中HT使用者的患病率。利用国家健康保险机构在2002年11月至2003年1月以及2003年11月至2004年1月这两个时间段的数据,评估自WHI发表以来罗讷 - 阿尔卑斯地区50 - 69岁女性中HT处方的变化情况。
50 - 69岁女性中HT使用者的粗患病率为52.3%(51.8 - 52.8),标准化患病率为35.7%(35.1 - 36.4),即约256万(251 - 259万)女性。标准化患病率在50 - 54岁年龄组最高,随后在年龄较大的组中显著下降(p<10⁻⁶)。在罗讷 - 阿尔卑斯地区,两个研究时间段之间HT报销显著下降(p<10⁻⁶),降幅从 - 14%到 - 45%不等,具体取决于所考虑的年龄组(65 - 69岁或50 - 54岁)。
尽管法国专业协会批评了WHI的结果,理由是法国使用的治疗方法不同——主要是经皮雌激素——且法国绝经后女性的血管风险低于WHI中的女性,但该研究的发布在法国监管机构(AFSSAPS)编辑HT处方限制建议之前就对处方产生了影响。必须进一步努力系统收集绝经后预防性治疗的信息,随后进行评估研究。