Chia S E, Koh D, Fones C, Qian F, Ng V, Tan B H, Wong K S, Chew W M, Tang H K, Ng W, Muttakin Z, Emmanuel S, Fong N P, Koh G, Lim M K
Faculty of Medicine, National University of Singapore, Singapore.
Occup Environ Med. 2005 Jul;62(7):473-7. doi: 10.1136/oem.2004.015024.
Singapore was affected by an outbreak of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) from 25 February to 31 May 2003, with 238 probable cases and 33 deaths.
To study usage of personal protective equipment (PPE) among three groups of healthcare workers (HCWs: doctors, nurses, and administrative staff), to determine if the appropriate PPE were used by the different groups and to examine the factors that may determine inappropriate use.
A self-administered questionnaire survey of 14,554 HCWs in nine healthcare settings, which included tertiary care hospitals, community hospitals, and polyclinics, was carried out in May-July 2003. Only doctors, nurses, and clerical staff were selected for subsequent analysis.
A total of 10 236 valid questionnaires were returned (70.3% response); 873 doctors, 4404 nurses, and 921 clerical staff were studied. A total of 32.5% of doctors, 48.7% of nurses, and 77.1% of the administrative staff agreed that paper and/or surgical masks were "useful in protecting from contracting SARS". Among this group, 23.6% of doctors and 42.3% of nurses reported working with SARS patients. The view that a paper and/or surgical mask was adequate protection against SARS was held by 33.3% of doctors and 55.9% of nurses working at the A&E unit, 30.5% of doctors and 49.4% of nurses from medical wards, and 27.5% of doctors and 37.1% of nurses from intensive care units. Factors which predicted for agreement that paper and/or surgical masks were protective against SARS, included HCW's job title, reported contact with SARS patients, area of work, and Impact Events Scale scores.
A variety of factors determine appropriate use of personal protective equipment by HCWs in the face of a major SARS outbreak.
2003年2月25日至5月31日,新加坡受到严重急性呼吸综合征(SARS)疫情的影响,有238例疑似病例,33人死亡。
研究三组医护人员(医生、护士和行政人员)个人防护装备(PPE)的使用情况,确定不同组是否使用了适当的个人防护装备,并检查可能导致使用不当的因素。
2003年5月至7月,对9个医疗机构中的14554名医护人员进行了一项自填式问卷调查,这些医疗机构包括三级医院、社区医院和综合诊所。后续分析仅选取医生、护士和文职人员。
共收回10236份有效问卷(回复率70.3%);对873名医生、4404名护士和921名文职人员进行了研究。共有32.5%的医生、48.7%的护士和77.1%的行政人员认为纸质和/或外科口罩“有助于预防感染SARS”。在这一组中,23.6%的医生和42.3%的护士报告曾与SARS患者共事。在急诊科工作的医生中有33.3%、护士中有55.9%认为纸质和/或外科口罩足以预防SARS;在内科病房工作的医生中有30.5%、护士中有49.4%持此观点;在重症监护病房工作的医生中有27.5%、护士中有37.1%持此观点。预测认为纸质和/或外科口罩可预防SARS的因素包括医护人员的职称、报告的与SARS患者的接触情况、工作区域以及影响事件量表得分。
面对重大SARS疫情,多种因素决定了医护人员对个人防护装备的正确使用。