Haywood Van B, Cordero Rafael, Wright Kellie, Gendreau Linda, Rupp Ronald, Kotler Mitchell, Littlejohn Sonya, Fabyanski Joyce, Smith Stuart
School of Dentistry, Medical College of Georgia, Augusta, GA, USA.
J Clin Dent. 2005;16(1):17-22.
This research systematically evaluated the use of a clinically proven desensitizing dentifrice prior to a bleaching regimen in a randomized, multi-center, parallel group, open label clinical study following Good Clinical Practice guidelines.
Fourteen dental offices in West Palm Beach, Florida participated in the study during April/May 2004. Fourteen days prior to bleaching, impressions and oral soft tissue assessments were performed, and patients were randomized to either a KNO3 plus fluoride dentifrice (Sensodyne Fresh Mint), or a standard fluoride dentifrice (Crest Regular), brushing 2x per day. On Day 14, patients returned to the dental office for their custom tray and the dispensation of a bleaching kit (Day White Excel 3; 9.5% hydrogen peroxide and KNO3). This was used daily according to the manufacturer's instructions for 30 minutes, and normal oral hygiene continued to be performed using the assigned toothbrush and dentifrice, brushing 2x per day. At the end of each bleaching day, patients answered diary questions about the occurrence and intensity of sensitivity. At the conclusion of the 14-day bleaching period (Day 28), patients returned to their dental office for re-examination, returning all products and diaries. Within seven days of completing the study, patients answered a telephone patient satisfaction survey.
A total of 202 patients in fourteen (14) dental offices completed all aspects of the study and were used for the analysis. The professionally dispensed bleaching product provided an improvement of approximately 4.4 Vita shades, regardless of whether it was used with the KNO3 plus fluoride (Sensodyne) or a standard fluoride (Crest) dentifrice. The patient perception of increased sensitivity caused by the bleaching treatment was low but measurable. In the first week of the bleaching, significantly more patients using the KNO3 plus fluoride dentifrice were free from sensitivity (58%) than the standard fluoride dentifrice group (42%). During the 14-day bleaching treatment period, the KNO3 dentifrice patients experienced significantly more "sensitivity free days" (average = 10.1) compared to the standard fluoride dentifrice group (average = 8.6).
The use of the KNO3 plus fluoride dentifrice (Sensodyne), two weeks prior to and throughout bleaching, may be a useful adjunct for the management of sensitivity caused by professionally dispensed bleaching products. With the bleaching-induced tooth sensitivity, those patients in the KNO3 plus fluoride toothpaste group were significantly more satisfied with their whitening experience and willing to repeat the bleaching treatment.
本研究按照良好临床实践指南,在一项随机、多中心、平行组、开放标签的临床研究中,系统评估了在漂白方案之前使用经临床验证的脱敏牙膏的情况。
2004年4月/5月期间,佛罗里达州西棕榈滩的14家牙科诊所参与了该研究。在漂白前14天,进行印模和口腔软组织评估,患者被随机分为使用含硝酸钾和氟化物的牙膏(舒适达清新薄荷味牙膏)组或标准氟化物牙膏(佳洁士普通牙膏)组,每天刷牙2次。在第14天,患者返回牙科诊所领取定制托盘和漂白套件(皓齿美白3;9.5%过氧化氢和硝酸钾)。按照制造商的说明每天使用30分钟,继续使用指定的牙刷和牙膏进行正常口腔卫生护理,每天刷牙2次。在每个漂白日结束时,患者回答关于敏感性发生情况和强度的日记问题。在14天漂白期结束时(第28天),患者返回牙科诊所进行复查,归还所有产品和日记。在完成研究的7天内,患者回答了电话患者满意度调查。
14家牙科诊所的202名患者完成了研究的所有方面并用于分析。专业分发的漂白产品无论与含硝酸钾和氟化物(舒适达)牙膏还是标准氟化物(佳洁士)牙膏一起使用,都能使牙齿亮度提高约4.4个Vita色阶。患者对漂白治疗引起的敏感性增加的感知较低但可测量。在漂白的第一周,使用含硝酸钾和氟化物牙膏的患者中无敏感症状的比例(58%)明显高于标准氟化物牙膏组(42%)。在14天的漂白治疗期间,与标准氟化物牙膏组(平均8.6天)相比,使用含硝酸钾牙膏的患者经历的“无敏感天数”明显更多(平均10.1天)。
在漂白前两周及整个漂白过程中使用含硝酸钾和氟化物的牙膏(舒适达),可能是管理专业分发的漂白产品引起的敏感性的有用辅助方法。对于漂白引起的牙齿敏感,含硝酸钾和氟化物牙膏组的患者对美白体验明显更满意,并且愿意再次进行漂白治疗。