Schifferstein Hendrik N J
Department of Industrial Design, Delft University of Technology, Landbergstraat 15, 2628 CE Delft, The Netherlands.
Acta Psychol (Amst). 2006 Jan;121(1):41-64. doi: 10.1016/j.actpsy.2005.06.004. Epub 2005 Aug 11.
Although popular belief holds that vision dominates human experience, this does not necessarily imply that people regard vision as the most important sensory modality during the interaction with every product. Instead, the relative importance of the different modalities is likely to depend on the type of product and on the task performed. In Study 1, respondents reported how important they found vision, audition, touch, taste, and smell during the use of 45 different products. In Study 2, the respondents answered a similar question for the evaluation of the safety, ease of use, and enjoyment experienced for 15 products. Importance ratings for the sensory modalities differed considerably between the products. Differences due to the types of evaluations were smaller. Averaged over products and evaluation types, vision was the most important sensory modality for product evaluations, followed by touch, smell, audition, and taste. However, for about half of the individual products, the importance ratings for vision were lower than for one of the other modalities. These findings are in line with the view that vision is regarded the dominant modality, because it plays an important part in many and an irrelevant part in virtually no product experiences.
尽管大众普遍认为视觉主导着人类体验,但这并不一定意味着人们在与每种产品交互时都将视觉视为最重要的感官模态。相反,不同模态的相对重要性可能取决于产品类型和所执行的任务。在研究1中,受访者报告了他们在使用45种不同产品时发现视觉、听觉、触觉、味觉和嗅觉有多重要。在研究2中,受访者针对15种产品的安全性、易用性和体验愉悦度评估回答了类似问题。不同产品之间感官模态的重要性评级差异很大。因评估类型导致的差异较小。综合产品和评估类型来看,视觉是产品评估中最重要的感官模态,其次是触觉、嗅觉、听觉和味觉。然而,对于大约一半的单个产品,视觉的重要性评级低于其他模态之一。这些发现与视觉被视为主导模态的观点一致,因为它在许多产品体验中起着重要作用,而在几乎没有产品体验中不起作用。