Brody Alan S, Sucharew Heidi, Campbell Jonathan D, Millard Steven P, Molina Paul L, Klein Jeffrey S, Quan Joanne
Department of Radiology, MLC-5031, Cincinnati Children's Hospital, 3333 Burnet Avenue, Cincinnati, OH 45229-3039, USA.
Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2005 Nov 1;172(9):1128-32. doi: 10.1164/rccm.200407-989OC. Epub 2005 Aug 11.
High-resolution computed tomography (HRCT) has been suggested as a potential outcome surrogate for cystic fibrosis (CF) lung disease. An important attribute of a valid outcome surrogate is that the surrogate reflects true clinical outcomes.
We performed this study to validate HRCT, a proposed surrogate outcome measure for CF lung disease, against a true clinical outcome, the number of respiratory tract exacerbations occurring in 2 yr, and to assess the correlation of CT scores and pulmonary function tests (PFTs) with this clinical outcome.
CTs and PFTs were performed on 6- to 10-yr-old children at the beginning and end of a 2-yr study during which the number of exacerbations were recorded. Spearman correlations and Poisson models were used to assess the correlation of the number of exacerbations with baseline values and changes in PFTs and CT scores.
Nine of 61 subjects had a total of 22 respiratory tract exacerbations. At baseline, PFTs and four CT scores showed significant correlation with number of exacerbations, but no variable by itself predicted exacerbations with high accuracy. For change over the 2-yr period, three CT scores showed significant correlation with exacerbations, whereas no PFTs showed significant correlation.
This is the first study showing correlation between CT and a true clinical outcome. Change in CT scores correlates moderately well with the number of exacerbation. Poor correlation between change in FEV1 and exacerbations suggests that HRCT may be a more appropriate outcome surrogate for longitudinal studies of young children.
高分辨率计算机断层扫描(HRCT)已被提议作为囊性纤维化(CF)肺部疾病的潜在替代结局指标。有效替代结局指标的一个重要属性是该替代指标反映真实的临床结局。
我们开展这项研究,以针对真实临床结局(2年内发生的呼吸道加重次数)验证HRCT(一种提议的CF肺部疾病替代结局指标),并评估CT评分和肺功能测试(PFT)与该临床结局的相关性。
在一项为期2年的研究开始和结束时,对6至10岁儿童进行CT和PFT检查,在此期间记录加重次数。使用Spearman相关性分析和泊松模型评估加重次数与基线值以及PFT和CT评分变化的相关性。
61名受试者中有9名共发生22次呼吸道加重。在基线时,PFT和四个CT评分与加重次数显示出显著相关性,但没有一个变量本身能高精度地预测加重情况。对于2年期间的变化,三个CT评分与加重情况显示出显著相关性,而没有PFT显示出显著相关性。
这是第一项显示CT与真实临床结局之间存在相关性的研究。CT评分变化与加重次数的相关性中等。FEV1变化与加重情况之间的相关性较差,这表明HRCT可能是对幼儿进行纵向研究更合适的替代结局指标。