Sarri Katerina O, Kafatos Anthony G, Higgins Siobhan
Division of Developmental Medicine (Human Nutrition Section), Yorkhill Hospital, Dalnair Street, Glasgow G3 8SJ, UK.
Br J Nutr. 2005 Aug;94(2):198-203. doi: 10.1079/bjn20051472.
The Orthodox Christian diet is unique in regularly interchanging from an omnivore to a vegetarian-type diet, and no study to date has focused on the impact of this on Fe status. Thirty-five Greek Orthodox Christian strict fasters (n 17 male, n 18 female; mean age 43.6+/-13.2 years) and twenty-four controls (n 11 male, n 13 female; mean age 39.8+/-7.6 years) were studied before (pre) and near completion (end) of the Christmas fasting (CF) period (40 d), during which meat and dairy products are prohibited. Fe status was assessed using standard haematological parameters, and Fe deficiency was determined via serum ferritin levels (<12 ng/ml) and the tri-index model. While fasters had marginally poorer pre haematological indicators, values were well above the cut-off levels, suggesting that intermittent fasting for a mean of 22.5+/-15.5 years did not have any substantial adverse effects on Fe status. During the CF period the changes in Fe status indices were more beneficial for fasters than for control subjects. In particular, fasters increased their ferritin levels (P = 0.02) and decreased their total Fe-binding capacity (P < 0.001). Compared with males, the effect of CF was more pronounced in female fasters. No subjects were detected with Fe deficiency at the end of the CF period. End dietary Fe and fibre intake were significantly higher in the fasters as compared with the control group (P = 0.038 and P = 0.001, respectively). Adherence to the Orthodox Christian dietary guidelines does not have a major impact on Fe status and is not associated with a significantly greater degree of Fe deficiency.
东正教基督徒的饮食有其独特之处,即会定期在杂食和素食类型的饮食之间切换,而迄今为止尚无研究关注这种饮食方式对铁状态的影响。对35名希腊东正教基督徒严格禁食者(17名男性,18名女性;平均年龄43.6±13.2岁)和24名对照者(11名男性,13名女性;平均年龄39.8±7.6岁)在圣诞节禁食(CF)期(40天)之前(预)和接近结束(末)时进行了研究,在此期间禁止食用肉类和奶制品。使用标准血液学参数评估铁状态,并通过血清铁蛋白水平(<12 ng/ml)和三项指标模型确定铁缺乏情况。虽然禁食者的血液学预指标略差,但数值远高于临界水平,这表明平均22.5±15.5年的间歇性禁食对铁状态没有任何实质性不良影响。在CF期间,铁状态指标的变化对禁食者比对对照者更有益。特别是,禁食者的铁蛋白水平升高(P = 0.02),总铁结合能力降低(P < 0.001)。与男性相比,CF对女性禁食者的影响更为明显。在CF期结束时未检测到铁缺乏的受试者。与对照组相比,禁食者的最终膳食铁和纤维摄入量显著更高(分别为P = 0.038和P = 0.001)。遵循东正教基督徒的饮食指南对铁状态没有重大影响,也与铁缺乏程度显著增加无关。