Earley M J, Abrams D J R, Staniforth A D, Sporton S C, Schilling R J
St Bartholomew's Hospital, London, UK.
Heart. 2006 Feb;92(2):233-8. doi: 10.1136/hrt.2005.066969. Epub 2005 Aug 23.
To investigate the feasibility of catheter ablation as a treatment for symptomatic patients with longstanding permanent atrial fibrillation (AF).
Radiofrequency ablation was applied to encircle all pulmonary veins (PVs) and create lines from the left inferior PV to the mitral valve, along the roof of the left atrium between the PVs, and along the tricuspid valve-inferior vena cava isthmus. A seven day Holter was recorded at discharge and at follow up to assess arrhythmia burden. If patients developed a symptomatic, sustained atrial arrhythmia a repeat ablation procedure was advised.
42 patients underwent the procedure that took a mean of five hours with 50 minutes of fluoroscopy. After a median follow up of 8.4 months, 31 of 41 surviving patients (76%) were in sinus rhythm. Of these, 29 patients were no longer taking any antiarrhythmic drugs but 22 (52%) required more than one procedure. During follow up 49% experienced a sustained atrial tachycardia. Twenty six repeat procedures were performed. Maintenance of sinus rhythm after the first, second, or third procedure was 36% (15 of 42), 58% (11 of 19), and 71% (5 of 7), respectively. From a total of 68 procedures there were two serious complications (2.9%): a stroke from which a full recovery was made, and a PV stenosis.
Catheter ablation can be used to cure longstanding permanent AF; however, there is a significant complication rate. Whether this is offset by a mortality benefit associated with sinus rhythm is unknown. Many patients will need more than one procedure to achieve success.
探讨导管消融术治疗症状性长期持续性心房颤动(AF)患者的可行性。
应用射频消融术环绕所有肺静脉(PVs),并从左下肺静脉至二尖瓣、沿肺静脉之间左心房顶部以及沿三尖瓣-下腔静脉峡部创建消融线。出院时及随访时记录7天动态心电图以评估心律失常负荷。如果患者出现症状性持续性房性心律失常,则建议再次进行消融手术。
42例患者接受了该手术,平均手术时间为5小时,透视时间为50分钟。中位随访8.4个月后,41例存活患者中有31例(76%)恢复窦性心律。其中,29例患者不再服用任何抗心律失常药物,但22例(52%)需要进行不止一次手术。随访期间,49%的患者出现持续性房性心动过速。进行了26次再次手术。第一次、第二次或第三次手术后窦性心律的维持率分别为36%(42例中的15例)、58%(19例中的11例)和71%(7例中的5例)。在总共68次手术中,出现了2例严重并发症(2.9%):1例中风且完全康复,1例肺静脉狭窄。
导管消融术可用于治愈长期持续性房颤;然而,并发症发生率较高。窦性心律是否能带来死亡率获益从而抵消这一风险尚不清楚。许多患者需要进行不止一次手术才能成功。