Ohtsuki Hisashi, Iwasa Yoh
Department of Biology, Faculty of Sciences, Kyushu University, Fukuoka 812-8581, Japan.
J Theor Biol. 2006 Apr 21;239(4):435-44. doi: 10.1016/j.jtbi.2005.08.008. Epub 2005 Sep 19.
The theory of indirect reciprocation explains the evolution of cooperation among unrelated individuals, engaging in one-shot interaction. Using reputation, a player acquires information on who are worth cooperating and who are not. In a previous paper, we formalized the reputation dynamics, a rule to assign a binary reputation (good or bad) to each player when his action, his current reputation, and the opponent's reputation are given. We then examined all the possible reputation dynamics, and found that there exist only eight reputation dynamics named "leading eight" that can maintain the ESS with a high level of cooperation, even if errors are included in executing intended cooperation and in reporting the observation to the public. In this paper, we study the nature of these successful social norms. First, we characterize the role of each pivot of the reputation dynamics common to all of the leading eight. We conclude that keys to the success in indirect reciprocity are to be nice (maintenance of cooperation among themselves), retaliatory (detection of defectors, punishment, and justification of punishment), apologetic, and forgiving. Second, we prove the two basic properties of the leading eight, which give a quantitative evaluation of the ESS condition and the level of cooperation maintained at the ESS.
间接互惠理论解释了不相关个体之间在一次性互动中合作行为的演变。通过声誉,参与者可以获取关于谁值得合作以及谁不值得合作的信息。在之前的一篇论文中,我们将声誉动态形式化,即当已知参与者的行为、其当前声誉以及对手的声誉时,为每个参与者分配二元声誉(好或坏)的规则。然后,我们研究了所有可能的声誉动态,发现只有八种被称为“领先八种”的声誉动态能够在包含执行预期合作和向公众报告观察结果时出现错误的情况下,以高水平的合作维持进化稳定策略(ESS)。在本文中,我们研究这些成功社会规范的本质。首先,我们刻画了所有领先八种声誉动态共有的每个关键因素的作用。我们得出结论,间接互惠成功的关键在于友善(维持自身之间的合作)、报复性(识别背叛者、惩罚以及惩罚的正当性)、歉意和宽容。其次,我们证明了领先八种的两个基本属性,这两个属性对ESS条件和ESS维持的合作水平进行了定量评估。