Cook Anthony, Salle Joao L Pippi, Reid Joanne, Chow Karen Fontana, Kuan James, Razvi Hassan, Farhat Walid A, Bagli Darius J, Khoury Antoine E
Department of Urology, Hospital for Sick Children, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Urol. 2005 Nov;174(5):1958-60. doi: 10.1097/01.ju.0000177483.65528.40.
Changes in referral patterns and resource allocation into Centers of Excellence affect the educational experience of urology trainees by altering resident exposure to patients and clinicians, especially at sites where subspecialty deficiencies exist. Access to educators at Centers of Excellence using interactive videoconferencing technology may facilitate residency training objectives and enhance trainees' overall educational experience. We prospectively evaluated the implementation of this technology at tertiary care teaching centers to enhance urology resident education.
Using videoconferencing technology, urology residents at the University of Western Ontario (London, Canada) participated in a series of didactic, interactive pediatric urology teleteaching seminars. These were presented by an expert pediatric urologist from the Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Canada. Using a 5-point Likert scale (1-strongly disagree, 5-strongly agree), participants responded to statements pertaining to seminar content, technology and ease of use at the completion of each session. The results were subsequently tabulated and evaluated to determine the effectiveness and accessibility of the program in providing expert pediatric urological education to residents at a remote urology training program.
The entire urology resident staff from postgraduate year 1 to 5 participated in the seminar program. The overall acceptance of this medium was high (mean score 4.5). The quality of presentation, as well as picture and sound quality, all received mean scores greater than 4. Participants indicated that their ability to interact with the presenter was not inhibited by using this medium. All participants agreed that they would use this technology in the future (mean score 4.5) and that the presentation would not be improved if the presenter were on-site. Due to preexisting technology at both centers, no direct cost was incurred throughout the study.
Our experience suggests that interactive teleteaching using readily available, existing technology, is a cost-effective and accepted method of providing trainees with an appropriate educational experience. In centers where subspecialty deficiencies exist, this medium may provide residents with the necessary education requirements of their respective programs without the need for costly teacher (or student) travel. Continual improvements in technology as well as the addition of multiple sites will increased this medium's impact in the future.
转诊模式的变化以及向卓越中心的资源分配,通过改变住院医师接触患者和临床医生的机会,影响泌尿外科住院医师的教育经历,尤其是在存在亚专业缺陷的地点。利用交互式视频会议技术与卓越中心的教育工作者交流,可能有助于实现住院医师培训目标,并提升住院医师的整体教育体验。我们前瞻性地评估了该技术在三级医疗教学中心的实施情况,以加强泌尿外科住院医师教育。
加拿大安大略省西部大学(伦敦)的泌尿外科住院医师使用视频会议技术,参加了一系列讲授式、交互式小儿泌尿外科远程教学研讨会。这些研讨会由加拿大多伦多病童医院的一位小儿泌尿外科专家主讲。参与者在每次课程结束时,使用5分李克特量表(1 - 强烈不同意,5 - 强烈同意),对与研讨会内容、技术和易用性相关的陈述进行回应。随后对结果进行列表和评估,以确定该项目在为远程泌尿外科培训项目的住院医师提供专业小儿泌尿外科教育方面的有效性和可及性。
从研究生一年级到五年级的全体泌尿外科住院医师都参加了研讨会项目。对这种媒介的总体接受度很高(平均得分4.5)。演示质量以及图像和声音质量,所有平均得分都大于4分。参与者表示,使用这种媒介并没有妨碍他们与主讲人互动的能力。所有参与者都同意他们将来会使用这项技术(平均得分4.5),并且如果主讲人在现场,演示效果也不会得到改善。由于两个中心都有现有的技术,整个研究过程中没有产生直接成本。
我们的经验表明,使用现成的现有技术进行交互式远程教学,是一种经济有效的、被认可的为住院医师提供适当教育体验的方法。在存在亚专业缺陷的中心,这种媒介可以为住院医师提供各自项目所需的必要教育,而无需教师(或学生)花费高昂的差旅费。随着技术的不断改进以及增加多个站点,这种媒介在未来的影响力将会增强。