Gerzina Tania M, McLean Tim, Fairley Jo
Faculty of Dentistry, University of Sydney, 2 Chalmers Street NSW 2010, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
J Dent Educ. 2005 Dec;69(12):1377-84.
The objective of this study was to explore perceptions of dental student clinicians and clinical teachers about dental clinical teaching to provide primary data for dental researchers and educators. Student focus group data provided background for development of a questionnaire that explored three themes related to clinical teaching. Twenty-one teachers and forty-five student respondents completed the twenty-five-item questionnaire in 2003. In the theme of the teacher/student relationship, no statistically significant differences were seen between teacher and student group perceptions. In the theme of educational theory applied in dental clinical teaching, a statistically significant difference was seen between teacher and student groups in the value of preclinical instruction in senior clinical years and in the value of a clinical log book. In the theme of skills required for clinical dental practice, a statistically significant difference was seen between teacher and student groups in the value of a critical appreciation of evidence-based practice as one of the skills. The study overall indicates that the dental clinical learning environment supports close perceptual conformity between students and clinical teachers in regard to what each group considers to be "good practice" in clinical teaching. The findings of this study indicate that some techniques that have been advocated to enhance clinical learning, such as evidence-based teaching methods, require further investigation.
本研究的目的是探究牙科学生临床医生和临床教师对牙科临床教学的看法,为牙科研究人员和教育工作者提供原始数据。学生焦点小组数据为一份探索与临床教学相关的三个主题的问卷的编制提供了背景。2003年,21名教师和45名学生受访者完成了这份包含25个条目的问卷。在师生关系主题方面,教师组和学生组的看法之间未发现统计学上的显著差异。在应用于牙科临床教学的教育理论主题方面,教师组和学生组在高年级临床阶段临床前指导的价值以及临床日志的价值上存在统计学上的显著差异。在牙科临床实践所需技能主题方面,教师组和学生组在将基于证据的实践的批判性评价作为一项技能的价值上存在统计学上的显著差异。总体而言,该研究表明,在临床教学中,牙科临床学习环境支持学生和临床教师在各自认为的“良好实践”方面有密切的认知一致性。本研究结果表明,一些被倡导用于加强临床学习的技术,如基于证据的教学方法,需要进一步研究。