Funama Yoshinori, Awai Kazuo, Miyazaki Osamu, Nakayama Yoshiharu, Goto Taiga, Omi Yasuo, Shimonobo Toshiaki, Liu Duo, Yamashita Yasuyuki, Hori Shinichi
Department of Medical Information Systems, School of Health Sciences, Kumamoto University, Japan.
Invest Radiol. 2006 Jan;41(1):1-7. doi: 10.1097/01.rli.0000188026.20172.5d.
The purpose of this study was to investigate how much radiation dose can be reduced without loss of low-contrast detectability with a newly developed adaptive noise reduction filter in hepatic multidetector computed tomography (MDCT) scans by using a computer-simulated liver phantom.
Simulated CT images, including liver and intrahepatic tumors, were mathematically constructed using a computer workstation to evaluate low-contrast detectability by the observer performance test. Milliampere second for construction of simulated images were 60, 80, 100, and 120 mAs (low dose) and 160 mAs (standard dose) at 120 kVp. Images with 60, 80, 100, and 120 mAs were postprocessed with the adaptive noise reduction filter. A total of 432 images were prepared and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis was performed by 5 radiologists. The detectability of simulated tumor by radiologists was estimated with the area under the ROC curves (Az values). In addition, we visually evaluated CT images of 15 patients with chronic liver damage for graininess of the liver parenchyma, sharpness of the liver contour, conspicuity and marginal sharpness of the liver tumors, and overall image quality.
The mean Az value at 0.777 (60 mAs), 0.828 (80 mAs), and 0.844 (100 mAs) without filter was significantly lower than that of 160 mAs without filter (P < 0.001, 60 mAs; P = 0.010, 80 mAs; P = 0.040, 100 mAs). There was no statistical difference between the mean Az value at 80 mAs with and 160 mAs without the adaptive noise reduction filter (P = 0.220) and 100 mAs with and 160 mAs without the adaptive noise reduction filter (P = 0.979). In the visual evaluation of patient livers, there was no statistical difference in the graininess and sharpness of the liver, the conspicuity and marginal sharpness of the tumor, and the overall image quality between standard-dose and filtered low-dose images (Wilcoxon signed rank test, P > 0.05).
The radiation dose can be reduced by 50% without loss of nodule detectability by applying the adaptive noise reduction filter to simulated and patient liver images obtained at MDCT.
本研究的目的是通过使用计算机模拟肝脏模型,调查在肝脏多排螺旋计算机断层扫描(MDCT)中,使用新开发的自适应降噪滤波器时,在不损失低对比度可探测性的情况下可以降低多少辐射剂量。
使用计算机工作站通过数学方法构建包括肝脏和肝内肿瘤的模拟CT图像,以通过观察者性能测试评估低对比度可探测性。在120 kVp下,构建模拟图像的毫安秒分别为60、80、100和120 mAs(低剂量)以及160 mAs(标准剂量)。60、80、100和120 mAs的图像用自适应降噪滤波器进行后处理。共准备了432幅图像,由5名放射科医生进行接受者操作特征(ROC)分析。通过ROC曲线下面积(Az值)估计放射科医生对模拟肿瘤的可探测性。此外,我们对15例慢性肝损伤患者的CT图像进行了视觉评估,评估内容包括肝实质的颗粒度、肝脏轮廓的清晰度、肝脏肿瘤的显见度和边缘清晰度以及整体图像质量。
未使用滤波器时,60 mAs(平均Az值为0.777)、80 mAs(平均Az值为0.828)和100 mAs(平均Az值为0.844)时的平均Az值显著低于160 mAs未使用滤波器时(P < 0.001,60 mAs;P = 0.010,80 mAs;P = 0.040,100 mAs)。80 mAs使用自适应降噪滤波器与160 mAs未使用滤波器时的平均Az值之间无统计学差异(P = 0.220),100 mAs使用自适应降噪滤波器与160 mAs未使用滤波器时的平均Az值之间也无统计学差异(P = 0.979)。在对患者肝脏的视觉评估中,标准剂量图像与经过滤波的低剂量图像在肝脏的颗粒度和清晰度、肿瘤的显见度和边缘清晰度以及整体图像质量方面无统计学差异(Wilcoxon符号秩检验,P > 0.05)。
通过对MDCT获得的模拟和患者肝脏图像应用自适应降噪滤波器,可将辐射剂量降低50%,且不损失结节的可探测性。