De Cauwer B, Reheul D, Nijs I, Milbau A
Department of Plant Production, Faculty of Biosciences Engineering Ghent University, Belgium.
Commun Agric Appl Biol Sci. 2005;70(1):17-49.
This multidisciplinary study investigates agro-ecological functions (nature conservation, agriculture, environment) and implications of newly created, mown sown and unsown field margin strips installed on ex-arable land to increase biodiversity. From conservational concern, the development of species rich field margin strips was not strongly affected by the installed type of margin strip since species diversity converged over time, whether strips were sown or not. Convergence between unsown and sown margin strips occurred also in terms of species composition: unsown and sown strips became similar over time. Mowing without removal of cuttings significantly reduced species richness, yielded more grassy margin strips and delayed similarity in species composition between sown and unsown margin strips. Species richness on the longer term was not significantly affected by light regime nor by disturbance despite significant temporary effects shortly after the disturbance event. On the contrary vegetation composition in terms of importance of functional groups changed after disturbance: the share of spontaneous species within functional groups increased resulting in higher similarity between the sown and unsown vegetation. Furthermore risk of invasion was highest in the disturbed unsown community on the unshaded side of a tree lane. A positive effect of botanical diversity on insect number and diversity was found. However the effects of botanical diversity on insect number was mediated by light regime. At high light availability differences between plant communities were more pronounced compared to low light availablilty. The abundance of some insect families was dependent on the vegetation composition. Furthermore light availability significantly influenced insect diversity as well as the spatial distribution of families. From agricultural concern, installing margin strips by sowing a species mixture and a mowing regime with removal of cuttings are good practices to diminish the risk of species ingrowth into adjacent crops by creeping roots and rhizomes. Seed dispersal was only problematic one year after the installation of the field margin strips particularly nearby the unsown margin strip and wind-borne seeds were dispersed over limited distances, mainly within 4 m of field margins. Annual herbage yield was not affected by mowing management. DM yield of sown/unsown communities converged over time. Compared to herbage from an intensively managed fertilized grassland, field margin herbage revealed a low feeding value, owing to a low crude protein content, a low digestibility and a high crude fibre content. The unsown community had a higher forage quality than communities sown to bred commercially available grass varieties. Both digestibility and crude protein content decreased over time irrespective of plant community or location. Mid June cuts were more productive than mid September cuts but digestibility and crude protein content was lower. The use of herbage from field margins as hay for horses or as a component in farmland compost are good alternatives. A strong relation was found between the distribution of pest insects and their antagonist families along field margin strips indicating a status of biological equilibrium. From environmental concern, field margin strips buffered boundary vegetation and watercourses against cropped areas loaded with high levels of mineral nitrogen. Margin strips reduced the mineral nitrogen content of the soil in the margin and mineral nitrogen loss during wintermonths. Mineral nitrogen loss was not affected by field margin type but by distance from the field crop. A minimal width of 5 m is necessary to reach an optimal reduction in mineral soil N and N losses.
这项多学科研究调查了农业生态功能(自然保护、农业、环境)以及在已开垦土地上新创建的、割草播种和未播种的田埂带对增加生物多样性的影响。出于保护方面的考虑,物种丰富的田埂带的发展并未受到所安装的田埂带类型的强烈影响,因为随着时间的推移,无论田埂带是否播种,物种多样性都会趋于一致。未播种和田埂带在物种组成方面也出现了趋同:随着时间的推移,未播种和田埂带变得相似。不清除割下物进行割草显著降低了物种丰富度,产生了更多草丛状的田埂带,并延迟了播种和田埂带之间物种组成的相似性。尽管在干扰事件后不久有显著的短期影响,但从长期来看,物种丰富度并未受到光照条件或干扰的显著影响。相反,干扰后功能组重要性方面的植被组成发生了变化:功能组内自发物种的比例增加,导致播种和未播种植被之间的相似性更高。此外,在树篱未遮蔽一侧受干扰的未播种群落中,入侵风险最高。发现植物多样性对昆虫数量和多样性有积极影响。然而,植物多样性对昆虫数量的影响受光照条件的调节。与低光照条件相比,在高光照条件下植物群落之间的差异更为明显。一些昆虫科的丰度取决于植被组成。此外,光照条件显著影响昆虫多样性以及科的空间分布。从农业角度来看,通过播种混合物种和采用清除割下物的割草制度来安装田埂带是减少物种通过匍匐根和根茎向相邻作物生长的风险的良好做法。在安装田埂带一年后,种子传播才出现问题,特别是在未播种田埂带附近,且风传播的种子传播距离有限,主要在田埂边缘4米范围内。年牧草产量不受割草管理的影响。播种/未播种群落的干物质产量随着时间的推移趋于一致。与集约化管理施肥草地的牧草相比,田埂边缘牧草的饲用价值较低,原因是粗蛋白含量低、消化率低且粗纤维含量高。未播种群落的饲草质量高于播种商业化可用草品种的群落。无论植物群落或位置如何,消化率和粗蛋白含量都会随着时间的推移而降低。6月中旬的割草比9月中旬的割草产量更高,但消化率和粗蛋白含量更低。将田埂边缘的牧草用作马的干草或农田堆肥的成分是很好的选择。发现害虫昆虫及其天敌科沿着田埂带的分布之间存在很强的关系,表明存在生物平衡状态。从环境角度来看,田埂带缓冲了边界植被和水道,使其免受富含高水平矿质氮的种植区的影响。田埂带降低了边缘土壤中的矿质氮含量以及冬季的矿质氮损失。矿质氮损失不受田埂带类型的影响,而是受与田间作物距离的影响。要实现矿质土壤氮和氮损失的最佳减少,最小宽度为5米是必要的。