Sheikh Aziz, Hurwitz Brian
Division of Community Health Sciences: GP Section, University of Edinburgh.
Br J Gen Pract. 2005 Dec;55(521):962-4.
Uncertainty remains about the extent to which findings from our previously published systematic review and meta-analysis of double-blind, randomised controlled trials of topical antibiotics compared with placebo in the management of patients with acute bacterial conjunctivitis treated in secondary care outpatient settings are generalisable to the management of the condition in primary care settings. We updated our review, undertaking searches, methodological assessment, data extraction and analysis according to a pre-defined protocol. In addition to the previous three included studies, we identified two additional double-blind primary care trials, one which compares fusidic acid gel with placebo gel and one which compares chloramphenicol eye drops with placebo eye drops in children. Meta-analyses of clinical and microbiological remission data reveal that topical antibiotics are of benefit in improving early (days 2-5) clinical (relative risk [RR] = 1.24, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.05 to 1.45) and microbiological (RR = 1.77, 95% CI = 1.23 to 2.54) remission rates; later (days 6-10) data reveal that these early advantages in clinical (RR = 1.11, 95% CI = 1.02 to 1.21) and microbiological cure rates are reduced (RR 1.56, 95% CI = 1.17 to 2.09), but persist. Most cases of acute bacterial conjunctivitis resolve spontaneously. While topical antibiotics are associated with significantly improved rates of early (days 2-5) clinical remission, this benefit is marginal for later remission (days 6-10).
对于我们之前发表的系统评价和荟萃分析(该分析对比了在二级护理门诊环境中治疗急性细菌性结膜炎患者时,局部用抗生素与安慰剂的双盲随机对照试验结果)在多大程度上可推广至初级护理环境中该疾病的管理,仍存在不确定性。我们根据预先定义的方案更新了我们的综述,进行了检索、方法学评估、数据提取和分析。除了之前纳入的三项研究外,我们还确定了另外两项双盲初级护理试验,一项对比了夫西地酸凝胶与安慰剂凝胶,另一项对比了氯霉素滴眼液与安慰剂滴眼液在儿童中的效果。对临床和微生物学缓解数据的荟萃分析表明,局部用抗生素有助于提高早期(第2 - 5天)临床(相对风险[RR]=1.24,95%置信区间[CI]=1.05至1.45)和微生物学(RR = 1.77,95% CI = 1.23至2.54)缓解率;后期(第6 - 10天)数据显示,这些在临床(RR = 1.11,95% CI = 1.02至1.21)和微生物学治愈率方面的早期优势有所降低(RR = 1.56,95% CI = 1.17至2.09),但仍然存在。大多数急性细菌性结膜炎病例会自发痊愈。虽然局部用抗生素与早期(第2 - 5天)临床缓解率的显著提高相关,但这种益处对于后期缓解(第6 - 10天)来说是微不足道的。