Haug Anita, Williams R B, Larsen S
National Veterinary Institute, Department of Pathology, Oslo, Norway.
Vet Parasitol. 2006 Mar 31;136(3-4):233-42. doi: 10.1016/j.vetpar.2005.11.024. Epub 2006 Jan 18.
For the assessment of coccidial oocyst production by chickens, some modified form of the McMaster counting method is commonly used. The objective of this study was to evaluate a standard method and to compare it to a new, faster method, in which all the preparative stages before counting are carried out in the same container into which the original faecal sample was collected. A stock suspension containing purified oocysts of all seven valid Eimeria species that parasitize chickens was prepared, from which seven concentrations of oocyst suspensions were made. Since the faecal material in a sample influences the ability of oocysts to float up in a McMaster chamber, the new method was tested to establish the optimal amount of faeces in the original sample. Control oocyst suspensions containing no faeces were also tested, and three series of counts using the new method were compared with the standard McMaster method. The results were statistically analysed by agreement analysis. Repeatability and between-operator variation of both methods were also tested by agreement analysis. Counting by the standard McMaster method underestimated the true number of oocysts. The new method gave counts in agreement with the true number of oocysts if using 1 g of faeces per sample. With 2 g of faeces, counts were obtained that agreed with counts by the standard McMaster method. Both methods showed agreement between repeated measurements. The new method used on a sample containing 2 g of faeces provides a convenient alternative to the standard modified McMaster method. A 1-g faecal sample increases agreement with the true numbers of oocysts. Processing of a sample with the new method is about nine times faster than with the standard method.
为评估鸡的球虫卵囊产量,通常采用某种改良形式的麦克马斯特计数法。本研究的目的是评估一种标准方法,并将其与一种新的、更快的方法进行比较,在新方法中,计数前的所有准备阶段都在收集原始粪便样本的同一个容器中进行。制备了一种含有寄生在鸡体内的所有七种有效艾美耳球虫纯化卵囊的储备悬浮液,并从中制备了七种浓度的卵囊悬浮液。由于样本中的粪便物质会影响卵囊在麦克马斯特计数室中上浮的能力,因此对新方法进行了测试,以确定原始样本中粪便的最佳量。还测试了不含粪便的对照卵囊悬浮液,并将使用新方法的三组计数与标准麦克马斯特方法进行了比较。通过一致性分析对结果进行了统计分析。两种方法的重复性和操作者之间的差异也通过一致性分析进行了测试。用标准麦克马斯特方法计数低估了卵囊的真实数量。如果每个样本使用1克粪便,新方法得出的计数与卵囊的真实数量一致。使用2克粪便时,得到的计数与标准麦克马斯特方法的计数一致。两种方法在重复测量之间都显示出一致性。在含有2克粪便的样本上使用新方法为标准改良麦克马斯特方法提供了一种方便的替代方法。1克粪便样本与卵囊的真实数量更一致。用新方法处理样本的速度比标准方法快约九倍。