Baylin Ana, Campos Hannia
Department of Nutrition, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts 02115, USA.
Curr Opin Lipidol. 2006 Feb;17(1):22-7. doi: 10.1097/01.mol.0000199814.46720.83.
This review compares fatty acid biomarkers to assess compliance in dietary intervention trials with their application in epidemiological studies.
Although many studies have used fatty acid biomarkers to assess compliance in short-term dietary intervention trials and habitual diets in observational studies, there is little information on the reliability and comparability of these measures. In this review, we summarize the usefulness and limitations of fatty acid biomarkers in clinical and epidemiological studies. As there are very few recent publications in this area, a complete literature review is provided.
Several options are available for the biological assessment of dietary fatty acids. The type of study (short or long-term), the metabolic characteristics and expected variability in the fatty acids of interest are major considerations when determining which tissues reflect a better measure of true intake. Certain fatty acids may not be suitable to assess differences in intake under non-isocaloric conditions and when trying to identify small differences. Serum cholesterol ester is the most suitable serum fraction to assess short-term dietary compliance, but given the multiple factors that affect response, the quantification of compliance should be interpreted with caution. Adipose tissue is the biomarker of choice for long-term intake, but a preferred blood constituent (plasma versus erythrocytes) is difficult to establish given the data available to date. Future studies should explore the use of whole blood as an alternative choice to measure fatty acid intake in epidemiological studies.
本综述比较了脂肪酸生物标志物在饮食干预试验中用于评估依从性的情况及其在流行病学研究中的应用。
尽管许多研究已使用脂肪酸生物标志物来评估短期饮食干预试验中的依从性以及观察性研究中的习惯性饮食,但关于这些测量方法的可靠性和可比性的信息却很少。在本综述中,我们总结了脂肪酸生物标志物在临床和流行病学研究中的有用性和局限性。由于该领域近期的出版物非常少,因此提供了完整的文献综述。
饮食脂肪酸的生物学评估有多种选择。在确定哪些组织能更好地反映真实摄入量时,研究类型(短期或长期)、感兴趣脂肪酸的代谢特征和预期变异性是主要考虑因素。某些脂肪酸可能不适用于评估非等热量条件下的摄入量差异以及试图识别微小差异时的情况。血清胆固醇酯是评估短期饮食依从性最合适的血清成分,但鉴于影响反应的多种因素,对依从性的量化解释应谨慎。脂肪组织是长期摄入量的首选生物标志物,但根据目前可得的数据,很难确定首选的血液成分(血浆还是红细胞)。未来的研究应探索将全血用作流行病学研究中测量脂肪酸摄入量的替代选择。