Umefjord Göran, Hamberg Katarina, Malker Hans, Petersson Göran
Department of Public Health and Clinical Medicine, Family Medicine, Umeå University, Sweden.
Fam Pract. 2006 Apr;23(2):159-66. doi: 10.1093/fampra/cmi117. Epub 2006 Feb 7.
Internet consultation without a previous relationship between the doctor and the enquirer seems to be increasing in popularity. However, little is known about the advantages, disadvantages or other differences compared with regular health care when using this kind of service.
To investigate how an Internet-based Ask the Doctor service out with any pre-existing doctor-patient relationship was used and evaluated by the enquirers.
We recruited to a web-based survey users of the non-commercial Swedish Internet-based Ask the Doctor service run by family physicians. The survey was conducted between November 2001 and January 2002. Questions included both multiple choice and free text formats, and the results were analysed quantitatively and qualitatively.
The survey was completed by 1223 participants. It was mainly women who submitted questions to the service (29% men, 71% women) and also who participated in the survey (26% men, 74% women). Most participants (77%) wrote their question at home, and 80% asked on their own behalf. Almost half of the enquiries (45%) concerned a medical matter that had not been evaluated by a medical professional before. After reading the answer, 43% of the participants indicated that they would not pursue their question further having received sufficient information in the answer provided. The service was appreciated for its convenience and flexibility, but also for reasons to do with the mode of communication such as the ability to reflect on the written answer without having to hurry and to read it more than once.
In the present study, we found that an Internet-based Ask the Doctor service run by family physicians on the whole was evaluated positively by the participants both in terms of the answers and the service. Internet-based consultation may act as a complement to regular health care. In future studies, the cost-effectiveness, patient security, responsibilities of the Internet doctor and the role of Ask the Doctor services compared with regular health care should be evaluated.
医生与咨询者之间事先没有医患关系的互联网咨询似乎越来越受欢迎。然而,与常规医疗保健相比,使用这类服务的优点、缺点或其他差异却鲜为人知。
调查咨询者如何使用和评价一种没有任何既存医患关系的基于互联网的“向医生提问”服务。
我们招募了瑞典由家庭医生运营的非商业性基于互联网的“向医生提问”服务的用户参与一项网络调查。该调查于2001年11月至2002年1月进行。问题包括多项选择题和自由文本格式,结果进行了定量和定性分析。
1223名参与者完成了调查。向该服务提交问题的主要是女性(男性占29%,女性占71%),参与调查的也是女性(男性占26%,女性占74%)。大多数参与者(77%)在家中写下问题,80%是代表自己提问。几乎一半的咨询(45%)涉及此前未由医疗专业人员评估过的医疗问题。阅读答案后,43%的参与者表示,在答案中获得足够信息后,他们不会再进一步追究问题。该服务因其便利性和灵活性而受到赞赏,也因其沟通方式的原因而受到赞赏,比如能够从容思考书面答案且可以不止读一遍。
在本研究中,我们发现由家庭医生运营的基于互联网的“向医生提问”服务总体上在答案和服务方面都得到了参与者的积极评价。基于互联网的咨询可以作为常规医疗保健的补充。在未来的研究中,应评估与常规医疗保健相比,基于互联网咨询的成本效益、患者安全、网络医生的责任以及“向医生提问”服务的作用。