Nijland Nicol, van Gemert-Pijnen Julia E W C, Boer Henk, Steehouder Michaël F, Seydel Erwin R
Department of Psychology and Communication of Health and Risk, Faculty of Behavioural Sciences, University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands.
Int J Med Inform. 2009 Oct;78(10):688-703. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2009.06.002. Epub 2009 Jul 21.
To identify factors that can enhance the use of e-consultation in primary care. We investigated the barriers, demands and motivations regarding e-consultation among patients with no e-consultation experience (non-users).
We used an online survey to gather data. Via online banners on 26 different websites of patient organizations we recruited primary care patients with chronic complaints, an important target group for e-consultation. A regression analysis was performed to identify the main drivers for e-consultation use among patients with no e-consultation experience.
In total, 1706 patients started to fill out the survey. Of these patients 90% had no prior e-consultation experience. The most prominent reasons for non-use of e-consultation use were: not being aware of the existence of the service, the preference to see a doctor and e-consultation not being provided by a GP. Patients were motivated to use e-consultation, because e-consultation makes it possible to contact a GP at any time and because it enabled patients to ask additional questions after a visit to the doctor. The use of a Web-based triage application for computer-generated advice was popular among patients desiring to determine the need to see a doctor and for purposes of self-care. The patients' motivations to use e-consultation strongly depended on demands being satisfied such as getting a quick response. When looking at socio-demographic and health-related characteristics it turned out that certain patient groups - the elderly, the less-educated individuals, the chronic medication users and the frequent GP visitors - were more motivated than other patient groups to use e-consultation services, but were also more demanding. The less-educated patients, for example, more strongly demanded instructions regarding e-consultation use than the highly educated patients.
In order to foster the use of e-consultation in primary care both GPs and non-users must be informed about the possibilities and consequences of e-consultation through tailored education and instruction. We must also take into account patient profiles and their specific demands regarding e-consultation. Special attention should be paid to patients who can benefit the most from e-consultation while also facing the greatest chance of being excluded from the service. As health care continues to evolve towards a more patient-centred approach, we expect that patient expectations and demands will be a major force in driving the adoption of e-consultation.
确定可提高基层医疗中电子会诊使用的因素。我们调查了无电子会诊经验的患者(非使用者)在电子会诊方面的障碍、需求和动机。
我们通过在线调查收集数据。通过患者组织的26个不同网站上的在线横幅广告,我们招募了有慢性疾病主诉的基层医疗患者,这是电子会诊的一个重要目标群体。进行了回归分析,以确定无电子会诊经验的患者使用电子会诊的主要驱动因素。
共有1706名患者开始填写调查问卷。其中90%的患者此前没有电子会诊经验。不使用电子会诊的最主要原因是:不知道该服务的存在、更倾向于看医生以及全科医生未提供电子会诊服务。患者有使用电子会诊的动机,因为电子会诊使他们能够随时联系全科医生,并且能让患者在看过医生后提出更多问题。使用基于网络的分诊应用程序获取计算机生成的建议,在希望确定是否需要看医生以及进行自我护理的患者中很受欢迎。患者使用电子会诊的动机很大程度上取决于需求是否得到满足,比如能否得到快速回复。从社会人口统计学和健康相关特征来看,某些患者群体——老年人、受教育程度较低者、长期用药者以及经常看全科医生的患者——比其他患者群体更有动力使用电子会诊服务,但他们的需求也更高。例如,受教育程度较低的患者比受教育程度较高的患者更强烈地要求提供有关电子会诊使用的说明。
为了促进基层医疗中电子会诊的使用,必须通过量身定制的教育和指导,让全科医生和非使用者都了解电子会诊的可能性和后果。我们还必须考虑患者的特征及其对电子会诊的特定需求。应特别关注那些能从电子会诊中获益最大但同时被排除在该服务之外可能性也最大的患者。随着医疗保健不断朝着更以患者为中心的方向发展,我们预计患者的期望和需求将成为推动电子会诊采用的主要力量。