Bailey F Amos, Williams Beverly Rosa
Birmingham VAMC, University of Alabama, Birmingham, USA.
Palliat Support Care. 2005 Jun;3(2):107-14. doi: 10.1017/s1478951505050182.
To identify factors associated with internal medicine interns' self-assessed competency in death pronouncement and to evaluate the effectiveness of a 10-minute death pronouncement module and pocket card guidelines.
In June 2003 at the Birmingham VAMC, Alabama, 48 internal medicine interns completed a survey of medical school education, training, and experience in death pronouncement and a self-assessment of death pronouncement competency. In September 2003, 33 of the 48 interns completed a follow-up training/education survey and rated their post-intervention competency. Using chi-square and paired t-tests, we identified factors associated with variations among baseline and post-intervention variables and examined pre-post changes in self-assessed competency levels.
At baseline, less than 30% of the interns had medical school instruction in the process of death pronouncement. More than 70% reported needing basic instruction/close supervision. Post-intervention, close to 90% interns needed minimal or no assistance. Over 50% reported using pocket card guidelines. We found significant pre-post increases in mean rankings in each of the 5 self-assessed competencies (p < .001). Factors associated with differences in baseline and post-intervention assessments included medical school training/experience and use of the pocket card guidelines.
When interns began training, most had no instruction in death pronouncement and felt unprepared for this task. With brief instruction, pocket card guidelines, and 3-months experience, the majority of interns reported needing minimal/no assistance in pronouncing death. A larger sample from multiple sites is needed to confirm these findings.
确定与内科实习医生自我评估的死亡宣告能力相关的因素,并评估一个10分钟的死亡宣告模块和袖珍卡片指南的有效性。
2003年6月,在阿拉巴马州伯明翰退伍军人医疗中心,48名内科实习医生完成了一项关于医学院校在死亡宣告方面的教育、培训及经验的调查,以及对死亡宣告能力的自我评估。2003年9月,48名实习医生中的33人完成了一项后续培训/教育调查,并对他们干预后的能力进行了评分。我们使用卡方检验和配对t检验,确定与基线和干预后变量差异相关的因素,并检查自我评估能力水平的前后变化。
在基线时,不到30%的实习医生在医学院校接受过死亡宣告流程的教学。超过70%的人表示需要基础教学/密切监督。干预后,近90%的实习医生需要极少或不需要帮助。超过50%的人报告使用了袖珍卡片指南。我们发现,在5项自我评估能力中,每项能力的平均排名在干预前后均有显著提高(p < .001)。与基线和干预后评估差异相关的因素包括医学院校培训/经验以及袖珍卡片指南的使用。
当实习医生开始培训时,大多数人没有接受过死亡宣告方面的教学,并且觉得自己对这项任务没有准备好。通过简短的教学、袖珍卡片指南以及3个月的经验,大多数实习医生报告在宣告死亡时需要极少/不需要帮助。需要从多个地点选取更大的样本以证实这些发现。