Kaloti Zaid, Nabaty Renieh, Mohamed Abubekr, Surapaneni Sarvani, Gaynier Anthony, Levine Diane L
Internal Medicine, Wayne State University Detroit Medical Center, Detroit, USA.
Medicine, Wayne State University School of Medicine, Detroit, USA.
Cureus. 2022 May 24;14(5):e25275. doi: 10.7759/cureus.25275. eCollection 2022 May.
Introduction Undergraduate Medical Education (UME) prepares future residents for many aspects of medical practice, but it is rarely all-inclusive. Death pronouncement (DP), a highly important aspect of clinical training for residents, seems to be inadequately addressed and taught in undergraduate institutions. Studies have indicated that most first-year residents received minimal DP training and felt unprepared for this duty. Despite being a challenging situation, a formal teaching course is not universally taught, with most institutions merely delivering point-of-care DP instruction to medical trainees provided by supervising faculty, senior residents, and nurses. Our primary objective was to provide formal education in Duties When Life Ends (DWLE), with the goal of enhancing familiarity, knowledge, and confidence in addressing the circumstances surrounding death for graduating medical students transitioning to residency. Methods As a part of a Transition to Residency (TTR) course for students entering nonsurgical specialties, we developed a curriculum to provide formal education to fourth-year medical students in DWLE that included a two-hour didactic session delivered virtually, followed by an in-person simulation session. The didactic session covered the history, processes of DP, death physical examination, identification of medical examiner (ME) case, education on how to deliver death news to family, information about autopsies and organ donation, distinction between the cause and mechanism of death, and documentation of death notes and certificates, as well as provider self-reflection and appropriate coping mechanisms for patient death. In the 45-minute simulation, students were divided into small groups and given a case summary. During the first half, they performed a physical examination and a verbal pronouncement on cadavers, followed by an interactive small group session where students reviewed the case and worked to identify the cause of death, determine if the death was a medical examiner's case, deliver death news to the family, and complete a death progress note and certificate. Pre- and post-session questionnaires were administered, assessing three components: process familiarity, knowledge, and confidence. Finally, participants assessed course usefulness and had a free response opportunity for comments and feedback. Results Overall, 198 students participated in all sessions, with 182 completing both pre- and post-session questionnaires. Pre-survey revealed that 70% of participants reported witnessing DP previously, with only 20% being familiar with the process of DP and 6% with documentation. Following the intervention, a comparison of the pre- and post-course questionnaires assessing process familiarity, knowledge, and confidence using a five-point Likert scale demonstrated statistically significant improvement in the mean scores in all three domains, with reported course usefulness of 96%. Conclusion A DWLE curriculum, as a part of the TTR course, was effective in improving self-reported familiarity, knowledge, and confidence regarding physician duties associated with patient death. The curriculum was well received by students. The incorporation of DWLE curriculum into TTR courses allows for vital preparation and education in the duties related to patient death. This may make a stressful process somewhat less stressful and may aid future physicians in developing competence in conducting these final physician duties.
引言 本科医学教育(UME)为未来的住院医师在医疗实践的诸多方面做好准备,但很少能涵盖所有方面。死亡宣告(DP)是住院医师临床培训的一个极其重要的方面,然而在本科院校中,这方面的教学似乎并不充分。研究表明,大多数一年级住院医师接受的死亡宣告培训极少,并且觉得自己没有为这项职责做好准备。尽管这是一个具有挑战性的情况,但正式的教学课程并非普遍开设,大多数机构只是由指导教师、高年级住院医师和护士向医学实习生提供即时的死亡宣告指导。我们的主要目标是提供关于生命终结时职责(DWLE)的正规教育,目的是增强即将毕业并过渡到住院医师阶段的医学生对处理死亡相关情况的熟悉程度、知识水平和信心。
方法 作为针对进入非外科专业的学生的住院医师过渡(TTR)课程的一部分,我们开发了一门课程,为四年级医学生提供关于DWLE的正规教育,其中包括一个两小时的线上理论课程,随后是一次面对面的模拟课程。理论课程涵盖了死亡宣告的历史、流程、死亡体格检查、法医案件的识别、如何向家属传达死亡消息的教育、尸检和器官捐赠的信息、死亡原因与机制的区别以及死亡记录和证明的填写,还有医护人员的自我反思以及应对患者死亡的适当应对机制。在45分钟的模拟课程中,学生被分成小组并得到一个病例摘要。在前半部分,他们对尸体进行体格检查并进行口头宣告,随后是一个互动式小组讨论环节,学生们回顾病例并努力确定死亡原因、判断该死亡是否为法医案件、向家属传达死亡消息以及完成一份死亡进展记录和证明。课前和课后都进行了问卷调查,评估三个方面:流程熟悉度、知识水平和信心。最后,参与者对课程的实用性进行评估,并提供自由作答的机会以发表意见和反馈。
结果 总体而言,198名学生参加了所有课程,其中182名学生完成了课前和课后的问卷调查。课前调查显示,70%的参与者报告称之前目睹过死亡宣告,只有20%的人熟悉死亡宣告流程,6%的人熟悉相关记录。干预后,使用五点李克特量表对评估流程熟悉度、知识水平和信心的课前和课后问卷进行比较,结果显示所有三个领域的平均得分都有统计学上的显著提高,报告的课程实用性为96%。
结论 作为TTR课程的一部分,DWLE课程有效地提高了学生自我报告的对与患者死亡相关的医生职责的熟悉程度、知识水平和信心。该课程受到了学生的好评。将DWLE课程纳入TTR课程可以为与患者死亡相关的职责提供至关重要的准备和教育。这可能会使一个压力较大的过程压力有所减轻,并可能帮助未来的医生在履行这些最后的医生职责时培养能力。