Wilson Margaret, Wilson Thomas P
Department of Psychology, University of California, Santa Cruz 95064, USA.
Psychon Bull Rev. 2005 Dec;12(6):957-68. doi: 10.3758/bf03206432.
When humans talk without conventionalized arrangements, they engage in conversation--that is, a continuous and largely nonsimultaneous exchange in which speakers take turns. Turn-taking is ubiquitous in conversation and is the normal case against which alternatives, such as interruptions, are treated as violations that warrant repair. Furthermore, turn-taking involves highly coordinated timing, including a cyclic rise and fall in the probability of initiating speech during brief silences, and involves the notable rarity, especially in two-party conversations, of two speakers' breaking a silence at once. These phenomena, reported by conversation analysts, have been neglected by cognitive psychologists, and to date there has been no adequate cognitive explanation. Here, we propose that, during conversation, endogenous oscillators in the brains of the speaker and the listeners become mutually entrained, on the basis of the speaker's rate of syllable production. This entrained cyclic pattern governs the potential for initiating speech at any given instant for the speaker and also for the listeners (as potential next speakers). Furthermore, the readiness functions of the listeners are counterphased with that of the speaker, minimizing the likelihood of simultaneous starts by a listener and the previous speaker. This mutual entrainment continues for a brief period when the speech stream ceases, accounting for the cyclic property of silences. This model not only captures the timing phenomena observed inthe literature on conversation analysis, but also converges with findings from the literatures on phoneme timing, syllable organization, and interpersonal coordination.
当人们在没有约定俗成的安排下交谈时,他们进行的是对话——也就是说,一种持续且很大程度上不同时的交流,在这种交流中说话者轮流发言。轮流发言在对话中无处不在,是一种常态,与之相对的情况,比如打断,会被视为需要修复的违规行为。此外,轮流发言涉及高度协调的时间安排,包括在短暂沉默期间发起讲话的概率的周期性起伏,并且尤其在双方对话中,两个说话者同时打破沉默的情况极为罕见。这些由对话分析者报道的现象,一直被认知心理学家所忽视,并且迄今为止还没有充分的认知解释。在此,我们提出,在对话过程中,说话者和倾听者大脑中的内源性振荡器会基于说话者的音节产生速率而相互同步。这种同步的周期性模式决定了说话者以及倾听者(作为潜在的下一个说话者)在任何给定时刻发起讲话的可能性。此外,倾听者的准备功能与说话者的准备功能呈反相位,从而将倾听者和前一个说话者同时开始说话的可能性降至最低。当言语流停止时,这种相互同步会持续一小段时间,这就解释了沉默的周期性特征。这个模型不仅捕捉到了对话分析文献中所观察到的时间现象,还与音素计时、音节组织和人际协调等文献中的研究结果相契合。