Allen Margaret Peg, Allison Melody M, Stevens Sheryl
J Med Libr Assoc. 2006 Apr;94(2 Suppl):E122-7.
As part of a project to map the literature of nursing, sponsored by the Nursing and Allied Health Resources Section of the Medical Library Association, this study identifies core journals cited in nursing education journals and the indexing services that cover the cited journals.
Three nursing education source journals were subjected to a citation analysis of articles from 1997 to 1999, followed by an analysis of database access to the most frequently cited journal titles.
Cited formats included journals (62.4%), books (31.3%), government documents (1.4%), Internet (0.3%), and miscellaneous (4.6%). Cited references were relatively older than other studies, with just 58.6% published in the 1990s. One-third of the citations were found in a core of just 6 journal titles; one-third were dispersed among a middle zone of 53 titles; the remaining third were scattered in a larger zone of 762 titles. Indexing coverage for the core titles was most comprehensive in CINAHL, followed by PubMed/MEDLINE and Social Sciences Citation Index.
Citation patterns in nursing education show more reliance on nursing and education literature than biomedicine. Literature searches need to include CINAHL and PubMed/MEDLINE, as well as education and social sciences databases. Likewise, library collections need to include education and social sciences resources to complement works developed for nurse educators.
作为由医学图书馆协会护理与联合健康资源部赞助的护理文献图谱绘制项目的一部分,本研究确定了护理教育期刊中被引用的核心期刊以及涵盖这些被引用期刊的索引服务。
对三种护理教育来源期刊1997年至1999年发表的文章进行引文分析,随后分析对被引用频率最高的期刊标题的数据库访问情况。
被引用的文献类型包括期刊(62.4%)、书籍(31.3%)、政府文件(1.4%)、互联网(0.3%)和其他(4.6%)。被引用参考文献的年代相对比其他研究中的更久远,只有58.6%是在20世纪90年代发表的。三分之一的引文仅出现在6种核心期刊中;三分之一分散在53种期刊的中间区域;其余三分之一则散布在762种期刊的更大区域中。核心期刊在CINAHL中的索引覆盖最为全面,其次是PubMed/MEDLINE和社会科学引文索引。
护理教育中的引文模式表明,与生物医学相比,对护理和教育文献的依赖程度更高。文献检索需要包括CINAHL和PubMed/MEDLINE,以及教育和社会科学数据库。同样,图书馆馆藏需要包括教育和社会科学资源,以补充为护理教育工作者编写的著作。