Barley Elizabeth A, Jones Paul W
Division of Physiological Medicine, Department of Medicine, St. George's, University of London, Cranmer Terrace, SW17 0RE, London, UK.
Qual Life Res. 2006 Jun;15(5):801-9. doi: 10.1007/s11136-005-5466-z.
Rasch analysis is now used widely to assess the measurement properties of health status questionnaires. This study tested the stability of the AQ20 - a dichotomous-response measure of health status in asthma, using parameters estimated by a Rasch model. One hundred forty-four asthma patients completed the AQ20 on five occasions over 3 months. At visit 1, two items showed significant misfit and were deleted. At each visit, the overall mean item-person and item-trait interaction statistics from the remaining 18 items (AQ18) were very similar. The repeatability of the item calibrations was excellent (intraclass correlation coefficient 0.95), despite the patients' health having changed (repeated-measures ANOVA: FEV(1) and AQ18 score p<0.0001). Tests of differential item functioning (DIF) over time showed that one item increased in severity. This item refers to ability to garden, and changes in response patterns could be related to seasonal changes over the study period. We conclude that this study has highlighted the usefulness of multiple repeat assessments which allow items to be tested for DIF over time. This is important as inclusion of 'time-dependent' items in a questionnaire may reduce the reliability of the instrument.
拉施分析如今被广泛用于评估健康状况问卷的测量属性。本研究使用拉施模型估计的参数,测试了AQ20(一种哮喘健康状况的二分反应测量方法)的稳定性。144名哮喘患者在3个月内分五次完成了AQ20问卷。在第一次就诊时,有两个项目显示出明显的不匹配并被删除。在每次就诊时,其余18个项目(AQ18)的总体平均项目-人及项目-特质交互统计量非常相似。尽管患者的健康状况发生了变化(重复测量方差分析:第1秒用力呼气容积和AQ18评分p<0.0001),项目校准的重复性仍非常好(组内相关系数为0.95)。随时间的差异项目功能(DIF)测试表明,有一个项目的严重程度增加。该项目涉及园艺能力,反应模式的变化可能与研究期间的季节变化有关。我们得出结论,本研究突出了多次重复评估的有用性,这种评估允许对项目随时间进行DIF测试。这很重要,因为问卷中纳入“时间依赖性”项目可能会降低工具的可靠性。