Burt Jonathan
Ferry House, Bottisham Lock, Waterbeach, Cambs CB5 9LN, UK.
Stud Hist Philos Biol Biomed Sci. 2006 Jun;37(2):295-310. doi: 10.1016/j.shpsc.2006.03.007. Epub 2006 May 16.
Solly Zuckerman's work has been largely dismissed or marginalized by both historians of primatology and primatologists. This paper, using archival and published materials, re-examines both his life and his research into primate sexuality and sociology in the 1920s, endocrinology in the 1930s, and the effects of bomb blast in the 1940s. Despite the many flaws in his work, which is now largely outdated, his career reveals a great deal about the audiences for primatological knowledge in pre-war and wartime Britain; the interlocking circles of the scientific community that impinged on primatology; and competing ideas of what constituted a scientifically correct methodology for the observation of primate behaviour. Also noted is the gap between Zuckerman's self-presentation as the scourge of anthropomorphism and the anthropomorphism of his remarks in private notebooks. Although his work well illustrates familiar themes of patriarchy, military and colonialism in the history of primatology, it also suggests another, underexplored dimension of that science: primatology as an example of cross-species social interaction.
索利·朱克曼的工作在很大程度上已被灵长类动物学历史学家和灵长类动物学家摒弃或边缘化。本文利用档案材料和已发表的资料,重新审视了他的生平以及他在20世纪20年代对灵长类动物性行为和社会学的研究、30年代的内分泌学研究以及40年代对炸弹爆炸影响的研究。尽管他的研究存在诸多缺陷,如今大多已过时,但他的职业生涯揭示了战前和战时英国灵长类动物学知识的受众情况;影响灵长类动物学的科学界相互关联的圈子;以及关于观察灵长类动物行为的科学正确方法的相互竞争的观念。还值得注意的是,朱克曼自称是拟人论的克星,但他在私人笔记本中的言论却存在拟人化,两者之间存在差距。尽管他的研究很好地说明了灵长类动物学史中父权制、军事和殖民主义等常见主题,但它也揭示了该学科另一个未被充分探索的维度:灵长类动物学作为跨物种社会互动的一个例子。