Yapijakis Christos, Panis Vassilis, Koufaliotis Nikos, Yfanti Georgia, Karachalios Stefanos, Roumeliotou Anastasia, Mantzavinos Zacharias
Department of Neurology, Medical School, University of Athens, Greece.
Eur J Oral Sci. 2006 Jun;114(3):175-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0722.2006.00352.x.
In order to test the detection feasibility of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) in saliva, a three-method blind screening analysis was conducted. Sixty-eight individuals were studied, comprising 34 HIV carriers and 34 noncarriers (controls) of matched gender and age. An oral examination preceded saliva and blood sampling of studied individuals. All samples were tested blind for HIV by using two immunological methods [Oraquick-compatible enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and a fluorescent immunoenzymatic method (ELFA)], confirmed by western blotting, and a simple molecular method (polymerase chain reaction amplification of a relatively constant viral DNA region), confirmed by DNA hydridization. Compared with the controls, about twice as many HIV carriers had oral health problems, including periodontal disease. ELFA resulted in 33/34 positives and 34/34 negatives in saliva, while it detected 34/34 positives and 34/34 negatives in blood. ELISA performed even better, with correct assignment of all positives and negatives in both saliva and blood. The PCR method, at three annealing temperatures, surprisingly detected all positive samples, while it gave no false-positive result. In conclusion, the detection of anti-HIV in saliva may achieve accuracy of 97.1-100%, comparable with that in blood. Furthermore, this study suggests that a highly accurate molecular method of HIV detection may be feasible, although the studied carriers had rather homogeneous characteristics.
为了测试唾液中人类免疫缺陷病毒(HIV)的检测可行性,进行了一项三种方法的盲筛分析。研究了68个人,包括34名HIV携带者和34名年龄和性别匹配的非携带者(对照)。在对研究对象进行唾液和血液采样之前先进行口腔检查。所有样本均采用两种免疫方法[与奥瑞快兼容的酶联免疫吸附测定(ELISA)和荧光免疫酶法(ELFA)]对HIV进行盲测,通过蛋白质印迹法确认,以及一种简单的分子方法(对相对恒定的病毒DNA区域进行聚合酶链反应扩增),通过DNA杂交确认。与对照组相比,HIV携带者出现口腔健康问题(包括牙周病)的人数约为对照组的两倍。ELFA在唾液中检测出33/34阳性和34/34阴性,而在血液中检测出34/34阳性和34/34阴性。ELISA表现得更好,在唾液和血液中对所有阳性和阴性结果的判定均正确。PCR方法在三个退火温度下令人惊讶地检测出所有阳性样本,且未出现假阳性结果。总之,唾液中抗HIV的检测准确率可达97.1% - 100%,与血液检测相当。此外,本研究表明,尽管所研究的携带者特征较为单一,但一种高度准确的HIV检测分子方法可能是可行的。