Sicotte Claude, Paré Guy, Moreault Marie-Pierre, Paccioni André
Department of Health Administration, University of Montreal, Montreal (Quebec), Canada H3C 3J7.
J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2006 Sep-Oct;13(5):557-66. doi: 10.1197/jamia.M2012. Epub 2006 Jun 23.
A risk analysis framework was used to examine the implementation barriers that may hamper the successful implementation of interorganizational clinical information systems (ICIS). In terms of study design, an extensive literature review was first performed in order to elaborate a comprehensive model of project risk factors. To test the applicability of the model, we next conducted a longitudinal multiple-case study of two large-scale ICIS demonstration projects carried out in Quebec, Canada. Variations in the levels of several risk dimensions measured throughout the duration of the projects were analyzed to determine their impact on successful implementation. The analysis shows that the proposed framework, composed of five risk dimensions, was very robust, and suitable for conducting a thorough risk analysis. The results also show that there are links between the quality of the risk management and the level of project outcomes. To be successful, it is important that the implementation efforts be distributed proportionally according to the importance of each of the risk factors. Furthermore, because the risks evolve dynamically, there is a need for high responsiveness to emerging implementation problems. Thus, implementation success lies in the ability of the project management team to be aware of and to manage several risk threats simultaneously and coherently since they evolve dynamically through time and interact with one another.
一个风险分析框架被用于审视那些可能阻碍组织间临床信息系统(ICIS)成功实施的实施障碍。在研究设计方面,首先进行了广泛的文献综述,以构建一个全面的项目风险因素模型。为测试该模型的适用性,接下来我们对在加拿大魁北克开展的两个大型ICIS示范项目进行了纵向多案例研究。分析了在项目全过程中所测量的几个风险维度水平的变化,以确定它们对成功实施的影响。分析表明,由五个风险维度组成的拟议框架非常稳健,适用于进行全面的风险分析。结果还表明,风险管理质量与项目成果水平之间存在关联。要取得成功,重要的是实施工作应根据每个风险因素的重要性按比例分配。此外,由于风险是动态演变的,需要对新出现的实施问题具有高度的响应能力。因此,实施成功取决于项目管理团队能否同时且连贯地意识到并管理多种风险威胁,因为它们会随时间动态演变且相互作用。