Significant effects of phosphorylation on relative stabilities of DNA and RNA sugar radicals: remarkably high susceptibility of h-2' abstraction in RNA.

The roles of nucleic acid radicals in DNA and RNA damage cannot be properly understood in the absence of knowledge of the C-H bond strengths depicting the energy cost to generate each of these radicals. However, previous theoretical studies on the relative energies of different nucleic acid radicals are not fully convincing mainly because of the use of oversimplified model compounds. In the present study we chose nucleoside 3',5'-bisphosphates as model compounds for DNA and RNA, in which the effects of both the nucleobase and phosphorylation were taken into consideration. Using the newly developed ONIOM-G3B3 methods, we calculated the gas-phase bond dissociation enthalpies and solution-phase bond dissociation free energies of all the carbohydrate C-H bonds in the model compounds. It was found that the monoanionic phosphate group (OPO3H-) was a better radical stabilization group than the OH group by 1.3 kcal/mol, whereas the neutral phosphate group (OPO3H2) was a significantly worse radical stabilization group than OH by 4.4 kcal/mol. Due to these reasons, the relative thermodynamic susceptibility of H-abstraction from deoxyribonucleotides and ribonucleotides varied considerably depending on the phosphorylation state and the charge carried by the phosphate groups. Strikingly, the bond dissociation free energy of C2'-H in ribonucleotides was dramatically lower than that of all the other C-H bonds by 5-6 kcal/mol regardless of the phosphorylation state and the charge carried by the phosphate group. This explained the previous experimental finding that radiation damage of RNA occurs mainly via H-abstraction at H-2'. A model study suggested that the strength of the hydrogen bonding interaction between the 2'-OH and 3-phosphate groups should dramatically increase from ribonucleoside 3',5'-bisphosphate to its C2' radical. The strengthened hydrogen bonding stabilized the C2' radical, rendering the C2'-H bond of RNA extraordinarily vulnerable to H-abstraction.